-->
Search the ArchivesNavigationContact InformationThe Citizen Newspapers For Advertising Information Email us your news! For technical difficulties |
Debate is good, misinformation badTue, 08/11/2009 - 2:51pm
By: Letters to the ...
I enjoy a good debate, one that is based on fact from both sides. It’s healthy and informative. But what I don’t like is when one side uses half truths and made up statements just to make a point and, in some cases, put fear in the minds of people who may not be completely informed. This is the case of Laura Lunsford’s letter of Aug. 5. Addressing Ms. Lunsford: First, in your very first sentence, you say, “We have won a small victory,” because a decision hasn’t been made on the Healthcare Reform Bill. It seems as though certain people are more interested in winning then working towards a compromise that will benefit the entire country. You also say the reform decision wasn’t reached because of the “pressure we the people put on our members.” Actually the delay is due to the pharmaceutical lobbyists, not “we the people.” Then, you say that during the August recess Congress will hear what their constituents think of “ObamaCare - and it isn’t pretty.” A recent poll taken by Kaiser says that 55 percent of Americans have put off needed medical care due to cost; 48 percent say they are suffering from health problems; 61 percent of all Americans think it is more important than ever to deal with health reform now, and in a Wall Street Journal poll, 76 percent of all Americans WANT the choice of private and public options in healthcare. I’d say the results are showing that the majority of Americans are in favor of reformed healthcare. You accuse people in government as blaming the doctors, insurance companies and pharmaceutical companies for the inability to pass the bill. Then you go on to question why the trial lawyers are innocent victims in this scenario. Sorry, I didn’t understand the comment about the trial lawyers. But as far as the others are concerned: There is a lobbying firm called PhRMA, which represents 32 drug companies. PhRMA has spent $6 million documented dollars in the past three months lobbying against healthcare reform. In addition to this $6 million, some of the drug companies have hired their own lobbyists, also contributing to the situation – Pfizer, $5 million; Amgen, Eli Lilly and GlaxoSmithKline, $3 million each. During a CNBC roundtable discussion on TV Tuesday night, which had representatives from the government, insurance companies and the medical field – someone brought to the attention of the Eli Lilly representative that they produce the most expensive and most profitable cancer drug at a cost of $38,000 for a one-year supply. His only response was that some insurance companies will pick up a portion of this cost. $38,000! According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics the average American’s annual wage is $40,400. When asked why the drug companies don’t stop the continuous advertising of drugs, leaving the decision up to doctor and patient and using those dollars to bring down the cost of the actual drugs, he could only answer by using the commercials for depression as an example that there may be people out there that don’t know they’re depressed and need to see the symptoms. You say that Mr. Obama feels the government can make better medical decisions for you and your family than you and your family. Right now we are NOT making those decisions. They are being made by the insurance industry and the cost of medical care. You claim the United States has the best medical care in the world. According to the CIA’s mortality list, when checking the statistics of 224 countries, the United States ranks 50th in longevity. Canada, which seems to be used as a comparison against government-run healthcare, ranks 8th. I attempted to look up the line you quoted from Tom Daschle regarding seniors, but when googling the quoted line, the only thing that came up was your article in this newspaper. There was no other reference to the former senator making any such statement. You also “quoted” former Governor Richard Lamb of Colorado, saying “old people have a duty to die and get out of the way.” If you had researched this statement, you would have seen that this was, in fact, not at all what he said. He never used the words “old people.” He actually said “we” and he was talking about ethical implications when using artificial means to keep someone alive when there no longer is any life. This was misinterpreted right after he made his speech and ran incorrectly in many newspapers. Many of them retracted the article, putting in the corrected quote. And, this speech was given in 1984 – 25 years ago – so I’m not sure where you find the relevance in today’s reform issue. No one wants to see yours, or anyone else’s, grandparents die early. In fact just the opposite. With healthcare reform and a public option, more people will have the ability to afford health insurance and medical care and will live longer and healthier lives. There is a tendency to believe that if the government is involved, then it will fail. What people seem to forget – because it’s been around so long – is that Medicare is government run. I’ve heard many a 65-year-old say they are so glad they can now sign up for Medicare and lose the high cost of their private insurance. Our veterans have VA insurance, which follows them throughout their lives, also government run. Let’s also not forget that our public schools, police departments and fire departments are also government run, and in most cases are very successful at it. The healthcare reform is simply an additional choice. If someone has private health insurance that they are satisfied with, both in coverage and in cost, then by all means keep it. But if someone doesn’t have health coverage due to cost, a pre-existing illness, or feels their premiums have become too expensive to afford, then hopefully the public options will be there as a choice for them. I’m sure we’re all in agreement that we’d like to see the United States move up the list, and out of 50th position, in life expectancy – and agree that we the people ALL deserve and have the right to be healthy. Debbie Pitts Peachtree City, Ga. login to post comments |