Racism behind furor?

Tue, 02/14/2006 - 5:00pm
By: Letters to the ...

In response to last week’s letter to the editor, “Fayette dumbing down tests for illegal students,” I am very disheartened to read so many letters about how Fayette County public schools are failing to “secure our borders” and keep illegal students out of our public schools.

I have the perfect solution to the problem in which ALL Fayette County public school students will benefit. Fayette County public schools should increase the grading scale from our current grading system (A = 100–90; B = 89–80; C = 79–71; D = 70; and F = 69 or lower) to the grading standards of more scholarly states (A = 100–93; B = 92–85; C = 84–77; D = 76–70; and F = 69 or below).

This is the grading scale I had in Pennsylvania over 25 years ago and the grading scale my son had in New Jersey seven years ago. My mother, who is the ripe age of 80, said her grading scale (in Massachusetts) was A = 100–95; B = 94-89; C = 88–83; D = 82–77; and F = 76 or lower.

It appears that Fayette County public schools (as well as many other Georgia school districts) are dumbing our grading standards to create the appearance of excellence.

Our family moved from Clayton County over two years ago and my children (elementary, middle, and high school level) adjusted to the move academically without any marked differences.

If Fayette County raises our current grading scale, I realize that my straight-A children may obtain B’s; but, I will have the assurance that my children’s grades are equivalent to some of the best schools in the country, not the state.

We must ask ourselves, are our Fayette County children academically equipped to compete globally?

If Fayette County public schools are serious about education, let’s not have our resource officers patrol our student parking lots and drop-off lanes for non-Fayette tags. But, let’s attack the problem intellectually.

With elevated grading standards, illegal students who cross our borders to attend our public schools will know that our grading criterion is more rigorous, and therefore, they must meet the challenge to remain in our schools, not go to the Department of Motor Vehicles and change their license plate tag.

Really, we are all dancing around the white elephant in the room, which is not a long academic history in Fayette County schools, or athletic recruitment, or school test scores, or real estate taxes, or home resale values. It’s plain and simple racism.

It’s not us (wealthy, Caucasian, law-abider) against them (poor, black, delinquent), but we are all in this together for the success of not only Fayette County’s public school students, but our nation’s children as a whole. They are our future.

Wendy Johnson
Fayetteville, Ga.

login to post comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
G35 Dude's picture
Submitted by G35 Dude on Wed, 02/15/2006 - 2:48pm.

I gotta agree with April here. Not wanting my tax dollars spent on students that don't belong here is not a racist issue. And I don't see how changing the relation of the letter grade to the number makes any difference either. Do away with letter grades. Let a 90 be a 90. Nothing more, nothing less.

The problem is that we have the best public schools in the state. Better than the national average is every way Mr. Hamster. This is why these illeagles are attempting to crash the party. And it'll still be that way even if you and Cooper Lighting move to Mississippi.

As for the comments about dumbing down the classes. Well isn't that why we have AP classes ? For the kids that can move on ahead of the average students ? I for one don't think any child SHOULD be left behind. Move the best and brightest to the AP classes, move the bottom group to remedial and teach the rest at the level that they can grasp !


H. Hamster's picture
Submitted by H. Hamster on Wed, 02/15/2006 - 7:11am.

All the Orientals, most Hispanics and some blacks and whites who apply themselves in school and have strong support from their parents are being dragged down by the blacks and whites who are at the bottom of their class and being catered to by the liberal elite's idea of fairness in education.


Submitted by april on Wed, 02/15/2006 - 7:07am.

Wendy,

I just can't seem to follow your line of reasoning here. Are you saying that if an out-of-county student is able to make A's, then it's ok for them to be in our school system?

And what about the comment "It’s plain and simple racism." What are you talking about? Are you saying that since most out-of county students are black that Fayette's attempt to boot them back to their own county school system makes Fayette racist? I don't think this accusation can possibly be taken seriously. We're talking about rules and tax dollars, plain and simple, not racism.

april

H. Hamster's picture
Submitted by H. Hamster on Wed, 02/15/2006 - 6:45am.

I used to have that same Yankee-influenced common-sense approach to education when I arrived here in the 49th state (yes we are and have a shot at #50 if Cooper Lighting transfers 12 people who have kids in schoool to Mississippi). However, our state laws and standards prevent the very things you mention for fear of "offending" someone or God-forbid "leaving a child behind" which used to mean making a student who flunks repeat a grade. Now it results in dumbing down the whole class so the last kid passes. Talk to some teachers (retired are best) and they'll gladly share the reasons we are not educating our kids.


mudcat's picture
Submitted by mudcat on Wed, 02/15/2006 - 8:00pm.

My neighbor is a retired teacher and she retired early for some of the reasons you bring up, mostly the dumbing down. When she and I and maybe you as well were in school the teachers spent 90% of their time teaching and the rest on administrative functions. Now they teach what they are told to teach perhaps 2 hours a day and spend the rest of the day on reports, disipline, showcase tasks and pure nonsense. She actually has had to submit reports that focus on a student's race before it reveals the student's test scores or anything else that used to be connected to education.

Why? How did we get to this point?

What can we do?
meow


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.