‘I prefer to have gov’t between me and my doctor’

Tue, 07/21/2009 - 3:40pm
By: Letters to the ...

Everywhere I turn these days I am confronted by editorials and op-ed articles concerning healthcare reform in this country. This Wednesday’s paper carried articles by such august professional columnists as Dick Morris and Cal Thomas, both of whom presented their opinions about healthcare reform as if they were fact.

Let’s see: Dick Morris works for FOX News and makes his living pandering to big money, conservative interests that pretty much oppose any changes to the status quo. I am sure that any informed newspaper is familiar with his past scandalous behavior. Morris is a whore who will write anything as long as he is well paid.

I don’t know who Cal Thomas is, but I see he is employed by the Tribune Media Services, Inc. Most probably he is bought and paid for by the same wealthy conservatives as Dick Morris.

Both of these gentlemen must have a crystal ball that enables them to see into the future, for they seem quite sure that universal healthcare will be a disaster.

I would just like to point out that our current system is completely inadequate and corrupt. Nearly 50 million Americans do not have health insurance at all and that means that they probably cannot afford the exorbitant cost of healthcare.

Private, for-profit insurance companies rule and they can, and do, deny critical healthcare to people who are ill to ensure their obscene profits. I just do not see how any government-run healthcare program could be as bad this.

Americans currently pay more for and get less healthcare than other first world countries. I think we need to change.

First, healthcare must be universal. Second, it must be affordable. The question is not whether or not to change, but what form that change should take.

I suggest that we stop listening to fear-mongers who oppose progress and listen to our new president who has access to expert counsel and whose responsibility it is to do what is best for all Americans, not just the privileged.

Furthermore I would prefer by a long shot having the government between me and my doctor than a profit-motivated insurance company.

It is high time that Americans demanded more.

David Browning

Peachtree City, Ga.

login to post comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
The Wedge's picture
Submitted by The Wedge on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 10:09am.

I am always amused to see a comment like this--"First, healthcare must be universal. Second, it must be affordable." because it shows the basic economic idiocy that most possess.
Health care is not an enumerated right in the Constitution. It never has been, but the desire to have an evolving constitution has made it inevitable. Of course, once our government has broken free from reasonable moorings, there is no guarantee where that ship will sail on the tyranny and thoughts of a majority and rabble. In any case, healthcare evolves to universiality.
Affordable is another matter entirely. The government will run universal healthcare the same way that it has run medicare and medicaid. They are already are running these and it is reasonable to expect similar results. And what are they? costs escalating way beyond projections, care and providers dwindling due to the low rates and payments authorized by the government. So in the end what will we have- a bureaucratic medical establishment that has a dwindling pool of providers, long wait times, and rationed care. For the 20 million or so that are uninsured although they want insurance, this will be better than they get now. The other people will have a decreased level of care. We will not raise the quality and lower the costs. The opposite will occur.


Submitted by Davids mom on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 1:12pm.

Fortunately, I have had little need to use 'health insurance' - but at this age I'm finding that there is a need. Most of the cost of medical service is paid from my Medicare account. The remaining cost comes from an insurance carrier that I selected. My doctors are always pleased when I present my insurance cards. They say they are paid within a reasonable time - and my records validate this. With so many complaining and in fear - are there many who are having a different experience with Medicare at this time?

Submitted by MacTheKnife on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 6:33pm.

The solution to most of our healthcare problems: Tort Reform.

In fact, ambulance chasing lawyers are responsible for a large percentage of the costs associated with health and medical care.

Ask any doctor what is single largest expense is .... insurance.... then ask why.

Lawyers in America are killing the goose that laid the golden egg in a number of areas from manufacturing to healthcare but they OWN the two major political parties.

cogitoergofay's picture
Submitted by cogitoergofay on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 9:03pm.

I hope that NUK/Mudcat/Jmart are enjoying the very soothing brainwash they have undergone in repeating the medical industry mantra that lawsuits raise the cost of health care. It is a myth.

I for one would be pleased if jury trials were abolished in medical malpractice cases. Congress could do it through a constitutional amendment. After all, medical malpractice is almost always a simple, unintentional mistake. So if we focused on simply the actual losses it could be fair to both sides.

But what has happened is that the medical industry has emasculated legal access while not in fact reducing medical care costs. It has simply raised physician and hospital profit. Take for example Georgia. Georgia enacted strong tort reform. Sonny Perdue bowed to the white coats and MAG Mutual. Georgia abolished any malpractice suits against any emergency room physicians or hospitals, for example. So, say a construction worker with a wife and two kids (and no insurance) gets injured in a construction accident, goes to the ER, the doctor makes an honest mistake and gives the wrong medicine and the worker is paralyzed from the waist down---- worker and family are barred from suit and get absolutely nothing. Did health care costs go down? No. Did doctors volunteering in poor areas go up? No.
Did doctor and hospital profit go up? Yes. Why is it that the medical care industry is tripping all over each other to tap in to profitable fields of medicine like oncology and cosmetic surgery but doing nothing in leading the way to a solution to our nation's biggest economic problem? Greed.

Justice may be prevailing though. Just as the two words you cannot say in an airport are bomb or gun, the two words you can't say at a doctors' convention are "medical tourism".


Submitted by MacTheKnife on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 12:57pm.

http://www.nal.usda.gov/ric/ricpubs/RHNsprsum02.htm

That is just one article on the topic worth reading.

You are not considering even remotely the amount of care prescribed to PREVENT the law suits from being filed and the number of operations and tests performed ... specifically in the OB field. The reason for the reform in Europe (and now in America since 2000) was required was because of suits like those filled by a recent presidential candidate (John Edwards) that were driving OB's out of practice and casing women facing high risk births in to a battery of tests, 'C' sections, and deliveries with staffs, additional nurses, life-flights on standby and entire units at hospitals like Egleston with level 3 and 4 NICU on standby at costs that you would find hard to fathom. Edwards and his ilk is the father of the 1.7 million dollar delivery and it is far more common than you know. Most of those costs are almost exclusively to avoid lawsuits and are not reflected in court cases but are certainly impacting the cost of healthcare.

NUK_1's picture
Submitted by NUK_1 on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 11:44am.

Georgia abolished any malpractice suits against any emergency room physicians or hospitals, for example

Uh, no they didn't. I don't know where you got the crap from, but it's totally inaccurate.

Here's the actual law:
"In an action involving a health care liability claim arising out of the provision of emergency medical care in a hospital emergency department or obstetrical unit or in a surgical suite immediately following the evaluation or treatment of a patient in a hospital emergency department, no physician or health care provider shall be held liable unless it is proven by clear and convincing evidence that the physician or health care provider�s actions showed gross negligence."

The standard is proof they exhibited "gross negligence." Sounds perfectly reasonable to me.


cogitoergofay's picture
Submitted by cogitoergofay on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 2:26pm.

J Mart: Yes, many OB tests are run unnecessarily but they are often run for a different reason--- to essentially get the Federal Government to underwrite the costs of an abortion. Feds pay for the test; the abortionist charges $79 for the abortion. And yet any member of Congress will deny that the Feds fund abortions even though the effect is precisely as described.

NUK: Suits against ER have been practically abolished. Gross Negligence--- look it up--- it means essentially that the doctor meant to do harm or exhibited such recklessness that intent is inferred. That NEVER happens in a medical setting. The injuries complained of are always an honest mistake. But the injured patient may in fairness need a remedy. In my example, the innocent construction worker who is the victim of an innocent mistake in the ER does not have access to the hospital insurance unless he can prove that it was nearly intentional. It never is. Therefore, no suits will ever succeed against the ER. You need to re-read the standard of "gross negligence" also coupled with the much, much higher burden of proof of "clear and convincing evidence." You will not find a lawyer who would represent the poor construction worker in my example. Sadly, costs have not gone down; profits have simply gone up.


S. Lindsey's picture
Submitted by S. Lindsey on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 9:43am.

that out of control Juries and Ambulance Chasing Attorneys are at least part of the problem..

The real strain on the system is coming from ILLEGALS getting true FREE care by coming in the ERs to get meds for a cold.. I have seen the full to overflowing rooms with maybe 5% speaking English..
Shut the Borders send the ILLEGALS home and then we can get a handle on cost...

They use our sysytem and never pay... so someone else has to... US.

"When the person who in possession of a government, shall say to a nation, I hold this power in 'contempt' of you, it signifies not on what authority he pretends to say it is..but an aggravation to a person in slavery"..Thomas Paine


Submitted by boo boo on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 9:43pm.

Yep, I see it for our future if health-care reform is not enacted. Instead of the World coming here for health-care most of us will be forced to go to a foreign Country to get our health-care because we won't be able to afford it. Actually it is already happening. Of course, if you have more money than God, no need to worry is there. I've got mine have fun getting yours...

Submitted by boo boo on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 9:22pm.

I was just reading tonight about Medical Malpractice in Florida. They too have enacted about the same practices on Medical Lawsuits as Georgia that cogitoergofay blogs about above. Almost impossible to bring a lawsuit against hospitals or Doctors in Florida as well.

Submitted by boo boo on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 9:02pm.

Malpractice suits.

Malpractice

A google box comes up on the above link saying it is broken but if you click on link the page will come up. Americans for Insurance Reform is the Web site.

NUK_1's picture
Submitted by NUK_1 on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 11:21am.

This is like the tobacco industry sponsoring studies that show that nicotine isn't "that bad." AIR is part of Center for Justice and Democracy, a far-left org that is all about litigation non-stop. AIR and CJD are against anything that reigns in ambulance chasers.


Submitted by boo boo on Sat, 07/25/2009 - 3:01am.

Who speaks for the people? Corporations have lobbyist, Insurance Co. have lobbyist, Doctors and Hospitals have Lobbyist. Just WHO speaks for the people? Are not, we the people, the important ones here? Our Senators and Representatives are sent to Washington to speak for us but most do not. Why, because they have been bought off or they just follow along like dogs and do what their leaders tell them to do. They have jobs so cushy, evidently, they can't take the chance of being thrown out of office so they just go along to get along.

Justice for All, isn't that what this Country is suppose to be about? Someone has to speak for We the people. Far Left or Far Right, if they speak for We the People so be it. The Far Right, the last 10+ years have only been the party of ME, when they become the party of WE again, then, maybe I will give them some thought...

Now those "LEFT" Blue Hound Dogs, I'm going to have to give them some more thought. As of now they are on my Doggies that aren't going to heaven list, but of course I could change my mind...I think all doggies should go to heaven, if given half a chance.

Submitted by Davids mom on Sat, 07/25/2009 - 8:36am.

Exactly why we should be flooding the email/phone lines/ etc. of our representatives with our opinions and directions on how to vote! They represent us! The lobbyist may give them big bucks - but they return to Washington by our VOTE! Even though your perspective may not be representative of the majority of the voters in an area - you still need to be heard.

Submitted by Davids mom on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 9:12pm.

Try this for malpractice information

Shucks - this didn't work either. This is the URL

http://www.insurance-reform.org/pr/090722.html

Submitted by boo boo on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 9:24pm.

You just have to click on the google link that pops up..You have to click on just the word "malpractice"

Submitted by Davids mom on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 9:39pm.

Hit three times! Nite!

Cyclist's picture
Submitted by Cyclist on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 5:06pm.

He also says he won't sign a health care bill that adds to the federal budget deficit.

So there might not be a health care bill after all.

-------------------------------------------
Caution - The Surgeon General has determined that constant blogging is an addiction that can cause a sedentary life style.


Submitted by Davids mom on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 4:55pm.

Her husband planned well, worked hard, saved money. They sent their only son to college - and then he was diagnosed with cancer. He had excellent insurance - which paid MOST of the medical fees. He died. His widow, who did not work, and did not have a group insurance plan - but was covered under her husband's plan-now pays $900 a month for health insurance. Fortunately she does not have a mortgage - and lives within her means - but her health insurance cost is the largest portion of her monthly budget. How many people in their 60's can afford $900 a month from their budget? She manages around that amount - because at that age, she can't afford to be without insurance.

Joe Kawfi's picture
Submitted by Joe Kawfi on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 11:00am.

Sounds like the widow and her dear departed husband (rest his soul) didn't do a good enough job of planning ahead. All the widow has to do is go find a job, just like many people in their 60's do.


mudcat's picture
Submitted by mudcat on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 5:53am.

And that is that the current system should change. The rest of your letter is BS, typical liberal lies and talking points.

If we want to change the system and make it better (as opposed to destroying the system and building another that is state-run) then look honestly at what is wrong with the current system. Too much oversight from the government, insurance companies and HMO's weaseling out of claims, unrealistic price-fixing and the biggie for all you whining liberals - poor, poor American families (think of the children) who do not have health care insurance.

OK, 2 fixes that liberals will like.
1. Subsidize the insurance companies by rewarding them for good behavior - like giving extra special care to disadvantaged Americans - poor people, illegal aliens, welfare queens and of course the chiilern.
2. Pay insurance premiums for the 10 or 20 or 40million people who don't have health insurance, depending upon which number you believe. Expensive? Sort of, but the insurance companies and health care industries will prosper and the economy will improve. If you want to throw in another bone to cure the economic woes, let the businesses that give their employees health care insurance a tax credit that makes it worth doing it.

Good, huh? Cheaper than Obamacare. Has everything a liberal should love except long-term political stranglehold on the dumb masses.

And Mr. Browning, Cal Thomas is not employed by Tribune Media, that is a distributor of syndicated columns written by free-lance journalists. Thinking he is someone's lackey shows how uncultured you are. Read Mr. Thomas for a month and you'll apologize for your foolish statement - well maybe not, if you are still a liberal - or a "progressive" as ashamed liberals are now rebranding themselves.


NUK_1's picture
Submitted by NUK_1 on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 4:42pm.

....trial lawyers and malpractice lawsuits at every moment of the day, driving up costs to everyone.


mudcat's picture
Submitted by mudcat on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 6:55pm.

The best trial lawyer in the world getting a gazzilion dollar settlement from insurance companies and that qualifies him to run for VP or even to be Honkie Prezbo?

Libs have some real good candidates and some even get elected.

And they really have helped the country they are trying to destroy. Trial lawyers? Community Organizers? Veterans turned traitors? Peanut farmers? Wow, what greatness.

I know, it is all Bush's fault.


Submitted by boo boo on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 1:55pm.

"We see change as our ultimate opportunity," said Stephen Hemsley, UnitedHealth's president and chief executive. "Change provides us the opportunity to create an even more significant and diverse enterprise serving the needs of Americans across this immense and growing social marketplace."

UnitedHealth posted profit of $859 million, or 73 cents a share, up from $337 million, or 27 cents a share, a year earlier. Prior-year items included legal settlements that hurt the period's profit by 40 cents. Analysts polled by Thomson Reuters were expecting earnings of 70 cents a share.

Revenue increased 7% to $21.66 billion, slightly below the average analyst estimate of $21.77 billion.

The health insurer also raised the lower end of its 2009 forecast by 10 cents and now expects a profit between $3 and $3.15 a share, straddling the average analyst estimate on Thomson Reuters of $3.07.

UnitedHealth shares have risen 52% from their March low, outpacing the 39% gain in the S&P 500 over that period. In midmorning trading, UnitedHealth shares rose 1.93% to $25.32.

Above Article from WSJ.

The above mention of Legal Settlements, mostly of which were fines for not paying, dropping health-care, for clients under UNH policy's.

The bottom line is these Health-care Insurance companies have No competition. With a Obama Health plan those Insurance companies would finally have competition and would be forced to reduce their policy's to compete with the Governments plan.

Everyone knows if a business has no competition they can raise their prices to the moon and the people can either afford that product or not. Our Health-care system is not working in this country for all of it's Citizens. Over 40 million people and counting have No health-care in A Country that is most prosperous in the world and yet we are not in the top 10 Countries with our Health-care System. What is wrong with this picture?

It is way past time for a change. It is only a matter of time before only the very rich will be able to pay for Health-care.

S. Lindsey's picture
Submitted by S. Lindsey on Wed, 07/22/2009 - 9:54pm.

get a job and support yourself.. Stop asking for another welfare program..
You entitlement give me a hand out crowd sickens us..
You want Socialized medicene.. go to Canada.. but wait.. it will take you a year for a non-citizen to see a doctor for non-emergency procedures.. So don't go with a pre-existing condition.. Get a life, get a job and stop asking the US taxpayer for a handout..

"When the person who in possession of a government, shall say to a nation, I hold this power in 'contempt' of you, it signifies not on what authority he pretends to say it is..but an aggravation to a person in slavery"..Thomas Paine


Submitted by Davids mom on Wed, 07/22/2009 - 10:18pm.

. .telling the citizens of the US who are experiencing the highest unemployment rate in recent history to 'get a job'. Small businesses and government institutions are laying off employees; increasing cost of health care is closing businesses. Thanks for the advice. We have representatives in Congress who SHOULD have the skills to work together to work out a solution to the problem of health-care in America.

Submitted by Davids mom on Wed, 07/22/2009 - 8:52pm.

Health care: Affordable, universal. Yes! Now we, the people, need to get involved and demand that those who represent us in Congress work this out – for everyone agrees that our health-care is essential to our future. If those who are part of the problem solving process would take the time to stop the fear mongering and work on solutions - we would be further along the way to better health care for all Americans.

Submitted by AtHomeGym on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 9:52am.

I have had the same Primary Care Physician for 20+ yrs. I saw him yesterday for a routine followup and blood work. I asked him about the proposed changes in healthcare. He said "Before I came here I was in the Army as a Doctor and was in charge or more than one clinic. The bureaucracy was unbelieveable and while we did the best we could for our patients, often that bureaucracy caused significant and unnecessary outcomes in patient care--so in short, I've experienced Govt managed healthcare first hand and it doesn't work."

Submitted by Davids mom on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 4:44pm.

Utilizing technology to correct the horrible bureaucracy of the medical profession is SUPPOSED to be corrected in some manner in the bill. The members of Congress need to stick to the task; work this out; so that the mistakes made in patient care are corrected. Are we saying this can't be done?

Cyclist's picture
Submitted by Cyclist on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 4:56pm.

It's not those "evil" republicans that are tying this bill up as the democrats enjoy the numerical majority in both the house and senate.
-------------------------------------------
Caution - The Surgeon General has determined that constant blogging is an addiction that can cause a sedentary life style.


Submitted by Davids mom on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 5:04pm.

Let's hope that the moderate Democrats (or whatever they're called) and some Republicans can get the job done to figure this thing out. If we can go to the moon - we can figure out how to make sure that Americans have a health-care plan that includes preventative methods/improved record keeping/affordable basic health care/affordable insurance costs. Let's hope that what is holding it up is the sincere desire to answer some of the concerns that many have about the plan - and get this thing settled.

Joe Kawfi's picture
Submitted by Joe Kawfi on Wed, 07/22/2009 - 9:40pm.

The fear mongering needs to stop with President Obama. He stood in front of the cameras this evening and used fear mongering to scare people into thinking that the future of America resides with his administration and their plans to nationalize health care.

He offers nothing new that hasn't been tried in the past. It has been proven time and time again that government intervention drives costs up and quality down. For example, look at the current education system in Washington. The average amount spent per pupil in the Washington system is $24,600. President Obama sends his two lovely girls to private school at a cost of approximately $28,500 per year, per student. The cost of public school (government run) in Washington is close to the same as the cost of private school because of government bureaucracy. The government has given us absolutely no reason to believe that they would run health insurance any differently. It will be nothing but a bloated, innefficient mass of government intervention that punishes the responsible and rewards the irresponsible.

The same fear tactics that President Obama used to get the stimulus plan passed has resulted in an unemployment rate of over 10%.

If the people that are part of the problem solving process would take the time to stop and read the President's bloated Health Care bill, they will see that it will lead our country down a long, downhill path into a pit that will be extremely difficult to climb out of.

Joe


Submitted by Davids mom on Wed, 07/22/2009 - 9:53pm.

Are you supporting the representatives that believe as you do? To get a bill that truly improves a system of health care that leaves so many uninsured - and is putting small businesses out of business - our leaders need to sit down, close the doors, and work out a better system now! We don't need to hear what won't work - they are there to develop something that does work. This isn't about Obama or GOP or elections in 2012 - it's about getting health care (affordable and universal). . .and that is the job of Congress to work it out- not go home for a vacation!

S. Lindsey's picture
Submitted by S. Lindsey on Wed, 07/22/2009 - 10:00pm.

Did you get in?
Did you wait for weeks or hours?
Did you see the doctor?
Did you get treated?

Let me answer..

YES
HOURS
YES
YES

So the system is not broke.. look past your liberal progressive entitlement give me another program ideology and stop asking the taxpayers of America to give you people another handout.

"When the person who in possession of a government, shall say to a nation, I hold this power in 'contempt' of you, it signifies not on what authority he pretends to say it is..but an aggravation to a person in slavery"..Thomas Paine


Submitted by MYTMITE on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 12:02pm.

I have worked all of my adult life--til retirement at age 68 and still work occasionally. I receive social security--which I was forced to pay into for years. I pay for Medicare as a deduction taken from my social security before I receive it. I scrimp and pay for supplemental insurance so I will be covered and also so I have no co-pay. I go with the basics on everything, be it cable, cell phone, or whatever. I am not asking and never intend to ask anyone else to take care of me. I do resent having to take care of others who do not use their money wisely. I also resent paying for the medical care of others who are not citizens. A few days ago I was in a business establishment, the person helping me was from another country (not Mexico), she is a citizen through marriage to an american serviceman. In between helping me she was on the phone talking to a young lady recently arrived here from her native country, who spoke no English and was having a hard time explaining to the lady at the Medicaid office what she wanted. Seems this young lady is already receiving Medicaid and was trying to approval for radiology tests. The lady helping me kept saying how sorry she was that the young lady was having so much trouble having people understanding her and how sorry she was for all the red tape she was having to go through. I was flabbergasted that someone in this country only a month or so was already receiving Medicaid when I know Americans who have had to jump through hoops for years to get help when they became disabled and could not work. This is what is wrong with our system. Our government takes care of these immigrants (legal or illegal) with hardly any questions asked, it insures or offers medical assistance to those who choose not to work (and don't bring up the economic situation today, we have had dead-beats collecting money and medical assistance for years with no effort to make them join the work force). Before they ask small business owners, working Americans and yes, even the rich, to pay more than their share they need to get these other situations taken care of. Every time we fight in another country, we end up letting thousands of those citizens come here and offer them all kinds of aid. It happened with Korea, Vietnam, and other 'wars'. We need to repair our country and stop trying to change the world. It hasn't worked in the past and it will not work in the present nor in the future.

Submitted by Bonkers on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 2:01pm.

I'll just bet that you have already collected from Social Security and Health costs (Medicare insurance) combined, than you paid in for your entire working life! The insurance you pay is a small fraction of the actual cost.
Aren't you glad that you "HAD" to pay it?

I don't know anymore about the person on the phone than you do.
If she is poor and has no job, yes she can get some assistance for health care. Someone who is dying will be treated in this country---whether or not they are yet a citizen!
I would expect no less in any other country where I got sick, legal or not.

Even if those deadbeats you mention join the work force, which many do, they still couldn't afford to buy insurance because the type job they get doesn't pay for it!

That is why we need Medicare for everyone!

Submitted by MYTMITE on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 5:43pm.

I may or may not have already used up more than I paid in--but I paid in. Because I was gainfully employeed I was not given a choice.I earend it. And if you think American citizens can go into any hospital or doctor's office and get the care they need--you are off your meds again. There are many instances of people with cancer and other life threatening illnesses that do not get the care they need because they work and do not qualify for financial assistance. There have been many American citizens who have died because they could not get the surgery or the medication needed. Every one should have the opportunity to have their medical needs taken care of-but it should not be on the backs of others when they have done nothing to make their situation better. We need to take care of our own before we open the flood gates to so many others and give them instant financial and medical help. Who is going to be there to help anyone when businesses large and small have to close and those employees end up on unemployment? People can only be taxed so much. Other nations have failed for these reasons and we are foolish if we believe it can never happen to this country. Please let me know what country allows immigrants (legal or illegal) to come into their country and immediately receive financial and medical aid. Most other countries have strict regulations about allowing immigrants in and usually only after they have proven they would be self-sufficient and offer something to the country they are wanting to enter,i.e, doctors, scientist etc. who bring something to the table and are a benefit to that country. What country do you think you could go in today with the exception of a few socialist countries that would take you in for medical treatment and not expect to be paid. If it were a socialist country you would probably die waiting to get in for that care.

Submitted by Bonkers on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 6:37pm.

I can't decide if you want people who are sick to have medical treatment, or not!
Sounds like you don't if they can't pay!

By the way your Medicare and Social Security payments are now "on the backs of others." That account has been empty some time. We are getting it off the contributions of the "boomers" who will soon be on it! No one to pay theirs at all!

Most people do pay into social security---they have to do so if they EVER work any! The company hiring them takes it out.

"The poor will always be with us," and it is not as bad as you think---about 7-8 percent are destitute. They won't break us!

Submitted by Davids mom on Wed, 07/22/2009 - 10:26pm.

I have insurance. Ask that question of those who don't. . . and I never have waited for longer than 20-25 minutes. Outstanding doctors in Fayette County and Piedmont Fayetteville Hospital.

Wrong again SL.

America to give you people another handout.

I'm sure you're talking about 'progressives' as 'you people'.

S. Lindsey's picture
Submitted by S. Lindsey on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 7:46am.

"
I have insurance. Ask that question of those who don't. . . and I never have waited for longer than 20-25 minutes. Outstanding doctors in Fayette County and Piedmont Fayetteville Hospital."

Then what the heck do you want UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE FOR???

90% OF AMERICANS ARE ALREADY COVERED.. UHC WILL ONLY COVER AN ADDITIONAL 7% ...There will still be 3% uncovered.
Why can't we cover the 18 million that really is uncovered and leave the rest of us alone.. 1.5 TRILLION at MINIMUM to cover an additional 7%.. This is all about power, Control and "setting right percieved wrongs"

Why DM does the bill have addtional rights for minorities.. setbacks and quotas... Why does this "HEALTHCARE" bill subvert States Rights and force them to accept Gay Marriage.. ?? WHY???

If this was really about Healthcare then you have to ask yourself why are these provisions in there... Oh yeah right.. you told me during the great "PORKULOUS" debate.. OBAMA is so intelligent that he allows these provisions in so he can veto them later..

How did that one work out DM?

"When the person who in possession of a government, shall say to a nation, I hold this power in 'contempt' of you, it signifies not on what authority he pretends to say it is..but an aggravation to a person in slavery"..Thomas Paine


Submitted by Davids mom on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 5:13pm.

Then what the heck do you want UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE FOR???

I have the choice to keep what I have. . .and I belong to a group that has excellent coverage. Universal does not mean you have to give up what you have and join another service UNLESS YOU CHOOSE TO DO THAT. . but that there will be a program for everyone. The problem is paying for those who don't have any insurance/health care. We figured out how to get health care for all of our children - and everyone did not drop the coverage they already had under their own policies and take advantage of the government plan. . .but our children in this country are covered.

S. Lindsey's picture
Submitted by S. Lindsey on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 8:55am.

Page 820 & 821

Provisions set forth that you as an individual "CANNOT" thats can't DM make any changes to their individual Health Plan if they opt out of the UHC plan.. If you make any changes at all... ANY changes.. you will immediately LOSE your individual option and MUST opt for the PUBLIC plan...

Choice... Is this choice DM??

"When the person who in possession of a government, shall say to a nation, I hold this power in 'contempt' of you, it signifies not on what authority he pretends to say it is..but an aggravation to a person in slavery"..Thomas Paine


Submitted by Davids mom on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 9:10am.

We'll see. At least the Congress is working - hopefully for the American people. There must be health care reform in this country.

S. Lindsey's picture
Submitted by S. Lindsey on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 9:16am.

simple questions.. Why is it all of sudden broke??
Do we have people dying in the streets...?
Dropping DEAD in ERs?

Why?

"When the person who in possession of a government, shall say to a nation, I hold this power in 'contempt' of you, it signifies not on what authority he pretends to say it is..but an aggravation to a person in slavery"..Thomas Paine


Submitted by AtHomeGym on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 1:02pm.

Charles Krauthammer has the answer: "Because rhetoric met reality!"

hutch866's picture
Submitted by hutch866 on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 5:43pm.

Maybe this guy is wrong, who knows. http://blogs.ajc.com/kyle-wingfield/2009/07/22/choice-is-a-casualty-of-obamacare/?cxntfid=blogs_kyle_wingfield

I yam what I yam....Popeye


Submitted by Davids mom on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 8:42pm.

I think we're just going to have the read the bill for ourselves - and make our own analysis.

A different point of view

mudcat's picture
Submitted by mudcat on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 4:03am.

Read the bill. Great idea. Looks like many are doing exactly that and they are raising some real interesting questions. So many that the brakes have been put on this horrible idea by Democrats, of all people - at least the sensible ones who still listen to their constituents back at home. It appears that once again the moderates of both parties have prevailed and Obama's (actually his handlers) phony crisis that has to be solved this week has been derailed.

There is no way he can reach so far so quickly and expect everyone to just sit back and let him ruin the country. The apathy and stupid idol worship of this empty suit lasted far longer than I would have thought, but thankfully it appears it is now over.

I hope Pelosi actually forces a vote on this because it will be defeated and those in the House that voted for the worst bill ever presented will be huge targets in next year's election. Sort of a replay of 1994 - backlash against stupid liberal ideas and a shifting of the majority to Newt and the Republicans. It will be good to see the grown-ups in charge and Prezbo neutered.


Submitted by Bonkers on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 7:55am.

So it is Newt you want? The man of a thousand ideas to alienate the world?

I wouldn't advise you to ever marry him because if you do and get sick, he will skedaddle!

Submitted by Davids mom on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 7:55am.

a different perspective - but hopefully a desire to reach the same goal. Those we've selected to represent us will work out a plan to sensibly fund healthcare reform. I'm sick of the grandstanding and the charts and the 'cute' statements from all sides. These Neanderthals and their egos must put politics aside and get this thing right. Now another problem - the minimum wage! Small business can't afford this now at a time when health care costs continues to escalate. WHERE IS THE REPUBLICAN PLAN THAT CAN SOLVE THIS ISSUE? Is the goal to denigrate Obama or help the American people?

Robert W. Morgan's picture
Submitted by Robert W. Morgan on Sat, 07/25/2009 - 6:32am.

If you do, you are sadly misinformed or have fallen under the spell of Prezbo. the Chosen One.

This is about creating a class of voter who like being dependent upon the governent and who will reliably vote Democrat for the next 40 years. Once they have that group under their thumb, the illegals next and all of a sudden it is a black and brown non-taxpaying majority in this country - all of whom vote blindly for the Democrat.

Read Carville's book, which explains this very clearly. All he leaves out is the incredibly transparent manipulation of the public by the President and the press who is totally in love with him. And a newsflash for you, the press is not as stupid as the public, they understand all this and welcome it.


Submitted by Davids mom on Sat, 07/25/2009 - 8:23am.

There are enough serious issues regarding health care in America without having to use the 'race-card' and 'fear-mongering'.

S. Lindsey's picture
Submitted by S. Lindsey on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 8:51am.

"WHERE IS THE REPUBLICAN PLAN THAT CAN SOLVE THIS ISSUE? Is the goal to denigrate Obama or help the American people?"

Welllll... here you go... Enjoy

The Plans

Try reading something for a change.. Stop spouting talking points..

"When the person who in possession of a government, shall say to a nation, I hold this power in 'contempt' of you, it signifies not on what authority he pretends to say it is..but an aggravation to a person in slavery"..Thomas Paine


Submitted by Bonkers on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 10:40am.

I read the plans! (Yours)

So, one must be able to choose the plan that fits his budget?

How many average wage workers ($17,000 each) can afford $18,000 for family insurance?
So he can not pick one can he, unless he wants no operations, no hospital stays, etc.

You refuse to recognize that the MAJORITY of workers can not buy decent insurance! And it is getting worse.

It will always be this way. We can not all make $100,000 per year and even if we did we wouldn't be able to afford what is coming for full coverage costs!

It is like the crooked banks: the health industry have run themselves out of a job by charging too much for insurance, and treatment, paying workers and managers too much (just as Eastern and Delta did)and beginning to completely ignore our worst off and sickest!

The end is nigh!

S. Lindsey's picture
Submitted by S. Lindsey on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 12:24pm.

"You refuse to recognize that the MAJORITY of workers can not buy decent insurance! And it is getting worse."

Care to provide some real facts instead of Rhetoric?

Here I will use one of the Progressive sites to give you some info..

Progressive Healthcare

"When the person who in possession of a government, shall say to a nation, I hold this power in 'contempt' of you, it signifies not on what authority he pretends to say it is..but an aggravation to a person in slavery"..Thomas Paine


Submitted by Bonkers on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 1:52pm.

I am not going to banter with you about health insurance any longer.
You sent out a web site that absolutely says precisely what I have been saying all along!!!!! You make no logic, or sense.

Did You read it?

Submitted by Davids mom on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 1:23pm.

That site provided the facts.

Submitted by Bonkers on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 1:54pm.

You didn't read it either!!!

Those facts have been illuminated here many times already. Why would Lindsey want me to even see them?

Folks read the web site Lindsey gave and tell me what it says!

Submitted by Davids mom on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 1:58pm.

It validated just what you said. Why the lash out at me?

Nuts! Smiling

Submitted by Bonkers on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 2:09pm.

I didn't lash out at you.
You agreed with Lindsey WHO IS AGAINST OBAMAS HEALTHCARE PLAN, I thought you were for it!

The thing Lindsey asked us to read supports what I have been saying for five years, almost exactly! Why, because that is the way it is.

The healthcare of 40 million here is bad and in danger for the rest of us!
Just who is going to pay 15-18,000 dollars out of their 40-50,000 dollars for health insurance? A high percentage , maybe 30% do not make that much.
Some don't even want them to make $7.25!!!!!!!!!!
It blows one's mind.

I think they think that we should have 30-40% of our people in bondage, so that at least some of them will have an incentive to be like them and make more money!

I don't know then who would do the hard and dirty work!

Submitted by Davids mom on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 2:13pm.

I didn't lash out at you.
You agreed with Lindsey WHO IS AGAINST OBAMAS HEALTHCARE PLAN,

I did not agree with Lindsey - I thanked him for sharing the facts as you had presented them. That was my intent.

Submitted by Davids mom on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 9:06am.

All of these plans say yes to universal coverage. Why are you saying that conservatives do not support universal coverage - and why should I as a 'progressive' not support uc? Is this what conservatives support - or is this just for information? What is the Republican plan for funding health care reform? I think that is what the members of Congress are trying to work out - and need more time to get it right. I wish them well.

S. Lindsey's picture
Submitted by S. Lindsey on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 9:13am.

as defined by OBAMA.. It took me almost a full day to completely go over all the Plans, supporting Docs and references.. WOW you did it 15 minutes.. I am impressed..

"When the person who in possession of a government, shall say to a nation, I hold this power in 'contempt' of you, it signifies not on what authority he pretends to say it is..but an aggravation to a person in slavery"..Thomas Paine


Submitted by Davids mom on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 9:19am.

Congress are reading the fine print and having their staff experts do the same. You are reacting to political 'talking points'. Congress has the responsibility of 'defining' this legislation. If this is not done in the interest of the American people - but in the interest of politics - a lot of the current members of Congress, regardless of party, will be going home!

S. Lindsey's picture
Submitted by S. Lindsey on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 9:37am.

Just like the porkulous bill.. time showed you that Obama can not be trusted.. This will not be any different..

Oh and haven't you heard.. THEY DON'T READ THE BILLS THEY SIGN.. THEY LAUGH AT US ASKING THEM TO DO SO.. THEY HIRE SPEED READERS TO DO IT FOR THEM.. THEY ARE LAUGHING AT US NOW..ONCE AGAIN.

"When the person who in possession of a government, shall say to a nation, I hold this power in 'contempt' of you, it signifies not on what authority he pretends to say it is..but an aggravation to a person in slavery"..Thomas Paine


Submitted by Davids mom on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 5:13pm.

Oops - hit it twice

mudcat's picture
Submitted by mudcat on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 5:35am.

They are now - no doubt. I have had several good experiences at Piedmont Fayette and never had unreasonable waiting periods.

Now, I suggest you do as I did and ask some of those same fine doctors what they think of Obamacare and what they plan to do if it gets enacted.

You will find that the thing they like best about it is the 3 year phase-in period. That will give them time to set themselves up outside the US (probably Bahamas or Cuba, if liberated) and prepare to treat the richest Americans fleeing socialized, government-controlled and rationed health care. It is a cash only business and all you have to do is make enough money to pay for a malpractice insurance policy. No forms to fill out. No one looking over your shoulder.

So, Davidsmom, if the good doctors and the well-heeled patients abandon the system, what is left? Mediocre doctors employed by the government? Obese patients being treated for diabetes until they reach 50, then treatment is cut off?

Good luck with that.

Fortunately this health care thing is self-destructing. Even if it doesn't and somehow gets passed in the House, the grownups in the Senate will kill it - just like that other liberal wet dream - Cap and Trade and Tax.


Submitted by Bonkers on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 12:16pm.

I realize that those of us who are rich and have health insurance would like to keep health care just as it is. (Those doctors aren't going to a third world to practice--they will make even more money.)

The new system is not for us!!!
We can keep what we have if we can afford it.

It is for 40-50,000,000 people who do not have insurance and don't like to beg for it and walk out on paying a $10,000 hospital and doctor bill!

No one who is making under $50,000 (most of us) can afford insurance unless our employer pays it, and they are quitting every day. Curently full coverage for a family is about $17,000 per year. Can you pay that out of 50 grand?

Something had to be done! Soon there would have been half of us with no insurance and unable to pay. (I paid nearly three hundred dollars for a semi-professional to just after-check a minor operation I had recently.

Most insurance has nothing to do with paying for eyes and teeth now!

I suggest that if we don't want insurance for everyone, then we also eliminate Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security, (use 401-ks as Bush said), Every state build their own Interstates, every state build their own F-22 fighters (GA could start in Marietta), and eliminate ALL taxes and put in a 50% sales tax--no exception to anything spent.

(Boy, what would a three days operation at a hospital cost then?).

Bologna would be $14 a pound and T-bones, $20. Milk $6, and fruit $10 a pound.

Cars would be $60,000--Mercedes $125,000.
Homes - (land- half acre--$120,000; house $600,000 for 3,000 SF.)

I can't even guess at what wages would be or what even "jobs" would be like!

We now run our economy having 30% of it spent for health care---mostly labor.
It must be reduced by eliminating waste and overcharges. Starting with Pharmaceutical companies and their hordes of well-dressed pitchmen.

Submitted by doright on Wed, 07/22/2009 - 8:39pm.

David,

I totally agree with you it is high time Americans stop pandering to fear mongering ON BOTH SIDES. It was the fear mongering that got us to pass a stimulus bill, it is fear mongering that passed a cap and trade bill through the house, and it is fear mongering that has made Speaker Pelosi trot out sick people, even one's who had cancer, to build support for a health care bill.

David, you are so right when American's give in to fear we stop reading bills put before us, we stop thinking logically and rationally and we rush to judgment.

Thank you for your reminder that we the American people need to demand more. We the American people need to be actively involved and need to make sure that our congressman read the bills before passing them.

And as an American I support you on you wanting to have the government involved in your health care and wanting the government to make those vital decisions for you. It's America you have that right BUT I also have the right to say no thank you to big government. I have the right to say to my congressmen that I would like them to do their very best in providing a solution to health care that does not involve the government and spending more trillions of dollars.

It is great to be in America where we can agree to disagree. I thank our military for those freedoms and David I thank you for reminding all of us that we Americans are intelligent thinkers and there is no place for fear.

zoes's picture
Submitted by zoes on Thu, 07/23/2009 - 11:57am.

If you want government provided health care, join the military.

ZoeS

"Never love anything that can't love you back."


S. Lindsey's picture
Submitted by S. Lindsey on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 9:01am.

Wasn't it just last year that Dems where beating the poor Veterians care over Bush's head..?? Now they want the same system for the rest of us???
I guess their answer is if you can't fix it.. give it to everybody..

"When the person who in possession of a government, shall say to a nation, I hold this power in 'contempt' of you, it signifies not on what authority he pretends to say it is..but an aggravation to a person in slavery"..Thomas Paine


Submitted by Bonkers on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 10:57am.

Well, since we sent in a few soldiers to attack the flat-landers poppies, in only this month (three weeks) we have had about 40 killed (of ours).
Haven't heard how many more to the hospital!

Do you have sny comments about how that is?
Might it get back to the hundres, thousands, again when we climb those big old cold Afghan/Pakistan mountains?

This is the war maybe we should have fought nine years ago when we had at least a little help!

I've got a relative in this mess. I want him home.

Submitted by Bonkers on Fri, 07/24/2009 - 10:44am.

So you admit Bush started the wars, caused the wounded, and did not plan to take care of them?

If not Bush, who? Newt, Sean, Rush, O'Reilly, the blond headed evil B....? Who?

Yeah, I know, Congress. Right.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.