Felon sues multiple agencies over drug case

Tue, 12/02/2008 - 2:35pm
By: Ben Nelms

Felon Johnathan Fenn wants to have another day in court and $3.8 million to go with it.

The Atlanta resident was sentenced to 25 years in prison for his part as get-away driver in a 2006 drug deal in Tyrone that injured two motorists he ran off the road when fleeing from officers.

Now Fenn wants to be on the other side in the courtroom. Fenn, acting as his own attorney, filed suit in federal court, citing 19 members of Fayette Sheriff’s Office and Drug Task Force (DTF), Tyrone Police, District Attorney Scott Ballard, three Georgia Bureau of Investigation (GBI) agents, three doctors and even his own attorney in the 2007 court case.

Fenn is alleging a host of felonious acts by the defendants related to his plea, such as use of excessive deadly force, conspiracy to obstruct justice, extortion, racial profiling, theft, selective prosecution and medical negligence and malpractice.

Fenn was involved in an August 2006 incident outside the Publix grocery store on Ga. Highway 74 in Tyrone. Fenn was one of four men involved in a drug deal involving 50 pounds of marijuana with DTF undercover agents.

As the driver of the vehicle, Fenn attempted to run down several deputies in the parking lot and hit a patrol vehicle. He was shot as agents opened fire.

Fenn evaded officers and drove the vehicle north on Hwy. 74 into Fulton County, striking a car in Fairburn. The occupants of the vehicle required hospitalization.

Responding to the suit, Ballard said that since the litigation was ongoing he did not feel it appropriate to respond to specific charges. Ballard did note the susceptibility to litigation that comes with his job.

“In this job defendants regularly sue me,” Ballard said. “I don’t think you can competently do this job without facing a lawsuit. I think this is an example of exactly that.”

Fenn, during court proceedings in March 2007, pleaded guilty to criminal attempt to traffick marijuana, three counts of aggravated assault, theft by receiving stolen property, possession of a motor vehicle with a removed or altered identification, fleeing and attempting to elude a police officer and reckless driving.

He was sentenced to 25 years in prison by Superior Court Judge Johnnie L. Caldwell, Jr.

In his subsequent federal suit filed in July and amended in September, Fenn claims that defendants collectively conspired against him, wrongly charging him with aggravated assault on the officers that shot him and with criminal attempt to traffick marijuana.

Fenn claims he never took possession of any drugs, never saw any marijuana and that there was no transaction with undercover agents.

He claims misuse of force, extortion and theft, excessive and deadly use of force, conspiracy to obstruct justice, selective prosecution, cruel and unusual punishment and denial of due process by a multitude of those with Fayette County law enforcement, the district attorney and three GBI agents, medical malpractice by three doctors at Atlanta Medical Center and his attorney in the 2007 court case.

“Defendants acted reckless in a Publix parking lot in plain disregard of the law — with requisite specific intent to do what the law forbids, and their actions amounted to clearly unreasonable and unnecessary excessive use of force,” Fenn said in the suit, adding that he was unarmed when being shot multiple times and in a coma for three days.

Fenn in his complaint is asking for a total of $3.8 million, including $1.25 million in compensatory damages from the numerous Fayette County law enforcement officers mentioned in the suit, the district attorney and his previous attorney, a total of $2.25 million in punitive damages from several Fayette County law enforcement officers and the district attorney and a total of $300,000 from the three Atlanta Medical Center doctors.

The suit claims that Fenn’s 4th, 5th, 6th and 14th Amendment rights were violated. Falling substantially along racial lines, Fenn claims that defendants in supervisory positions had informants “travel out of their jurisdiction with no probably cause or reasonable cause to black neighborhoods and places of business, to initiate the commission, then lured them to Fayette County, to be extorted of their property and money, then punished by their government. The defendants' illegal conduct in regards to ‘Buy-Bust’ and ‘Reverse’ sting operation, to incarcerate African American that have no social or criminal ties to their community is motivated by racially discriminatory animus.”

Fenn goes on to claim that Fayette County government instituted a conspiracy, either directly or indirectly, violating his right to equal protection under the law. He also claims that Ann Shafer, his attorney in his 2007 case, conspired with defendants to scare, influence and coerce him to plead guilty to the criminal charges.

Other charges in the suit include numerous inappropriate conditions at the Fayette County Jail infirmary and, relating to three doctors at Atlanta Medical Center, “inexcusable negligence, medical malpractice and deliberate indifference toward allowing the lead (bullet) fragments to remain” in his body and critically exposing him to lead toxicity.

login to post comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Submitted by mysteryman on Sun, 01/04/2009 - 12:34pm.

You aint gots no rights holmes, For the courts to even consider this is unacceptable, you did the crime now man up, and do the time bro.. Hope you stocked up on soap on a rope holmes, cause you goin fo the big ride, be blessed, for they ought to fry ya, and save us taxpayers some money....Heres 2 ya..main...

TinCan's picture
Submitted by TinCan on Sun, 01/04/2009 - 3:04pm.

MM,
Just to help with your street cred in the hood, I believe it's homes, as in homey, home boy. If your advice is for Sherlock I apologise for butting in. Yours in honkeydom.


Submitted by mysteryman on Sun, 01/04/2009 - 3:41pm.

Its allgood main, props to ya tin main, go head on and brake me off that 4d ounce O.E. me and the homies we be rydin ups to dis be it ats the pabillion main, gona gets some of dat hot fish and chyps dare holmes hits us up on da one main c ya dere...peaceout..

TinCan's picture
Submitted by TinCan on Sun, 01/04/2009 - 3:52pm.

Sorry, didn't realize you were under cover.


Submitted by FayetteFlyer on Sun, 12/14/2008 - 4:11pm.

At least he'll have the next 25 years to work on his appeal process. This is one jailhouse lawyer we won't worry about seeing for some time.

The 5-0's picture
Submitted by The 5-0 on Fri, 12/05/2008 - 9:03am.

“...travel out of their jurisdiction with no probably cause"

hahahahahaha

If you don't know that it's supposed to be "probable cause" then maybe you shouldn't represent yourself in court.

I hope he enjoys his 25 years in prison.


Submitted by mikese on Wed, 03/11/2009 - 12:07pm.

Dealers should get locked up the users though i think should have a chance with addiction treatment and kick their habit it's not their fault they are addicted no different then people smoking cigarettes who find it extremely hard to quit.

Submitted by skyspy on Tue, 12/02/2008 - 7:36pm.

Listen up fenn

You are a waste of the clean water I need to wash my cars every day. No one feels sorry for you. YOU CHOSE to break the law, and you got caught. Even in your cesspool, ghetto Atlanta I doubt anybody feels sorry for you. You are a piece of garbage that should have never gotten away alive.!!!!! You are the reason people here get carry conceal permits....and use them!!!! No one would miss you if you "accidently" OD on your own junk that you sell to young kids. Give it whirl lets see what happens.

You made a HUGE mistake when YOU...CHOSE to commit a crime in Fayette County.....The only good criminal is a dead one. Thanks for again giving me a good reason to justify my guns and my carry permit. You are a STRONG argument for abortion.

Attention Scott Ballard: Please, please, please, please pick me for jury duty...please.....I have yet to serve in Fayette County, and I feel it is my civic duty......pleeeeeaaaasssseeeee.....

Submitted by DWKK07 on Tue, 12/02/2008 - 6:31pm.

Too bad the deputy shooting the assault rifle at him wasn't a better shot. This guy is a moron. Maybe we should take up the policy used by some other countries - completely removing the assurance of civil abilities and rights (like suing people) from convicted felons.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.