E-SPLOST’s anti-senior campaign

Steve Brown's picture

As I write this column, I cannot help but think of Irene Dunne’s famous quote, “If we don’t stand for something, we will fall for anything.”

I chose to preempt the intended column for this week to address something along the same lines which bothers me. I will follow on how the bonds went wrong, key decisions went awry and identifying those who are benefiting from all of it next week.

The E-SPLOST for schools vote is creating a moral gut-check for voters. There is a scheme afoot to blame our senior citizens for the failure of two previous school SPLOST attempts in Fayette County. In doing so, the hope is to have young families disregard the failures of the FCBOE and view to seniors as the enemy. Likewise, such a ploy could attempt to embarrass senior citizens into funding the public school system even more.

This propaganda campaign is disseminated through a school board member and key members of a group called Fayette Citizens for Children. The political maneuver is necessary since it has become very difficult to support the SPLOST based on the previous argument of school overcrowding and funding issues.

I, unquestionably, believe we have a moral obligation to protect our senior citizens, also known as our parents and grandparents.

In this day and age, it is certainly a risk talking openly about public conscience or appealing to the populace’s sense of right and wrong. Even our churches will avoid these topics in lieu of softer themes because they do not want to offend some of their unapologetic members.

However, it is easy to see there are malevolent forces in our culture who will say do whatever you like as long as you feel good. This movement of self-fulfillment at the expense of others shatters the public trust and creates social ruin.

Keep this in mind, for every home where senior citizens reside, you have two less children per home in our school system. Less children equates to less expense and less taxation. Senior citizens are very good for our area for a number of reasons and we need them in our community.

There is gossip circulating that senior citizens do not pay school taxes. This is not true. There are certain age levels and income brackets that earn various degrees of exemption from school taxes.

Fayette County Board of Education (FCBOE) member Janet Smola started the anti-seniors campaign with an email to the president of a subdivision in Kedron Village. The email has since been circulating all across the county. In the correspondence, Ms. Smola declares the “elderly” are the reason our SPLOSTs do not pass.

I hate to hear a local widow, who is just barely making it, say that she does not want to be the reason the children cannot have class.

First of all, she is not the reason, and there are plenty of classes. Second, she has paid taxes all her adult life, a fair share. Third, out of respect (anyone remember respect?), we ought to honor our seniors’ hard work and sacrifice and give them any break we can in their last stage of life.

Contradicting herself, back in 1999, the same Ms. Smola was the chairwoman of a political action committee designed to ram the then-SPLOST referendum through. The SPLOST failed and Ms. Smola did not blame the senior citizens then as she does now.

The truth is she blamed a single person for the failure of the county-wide vote: Carl Avrit (The Citizen, “SPLOST, ethics law, free speech clash,” Feb. 2, 2000; “Ethics Commission cites anti-SPLOST action committee,” Dec. 22, 1999; “Ethics panel hears Fayette case Monday,” Dec. 15, 1999).

Mr. Avrit sent computerized calls to homes opposing the SPLOST. To think that one man’s phone calls could have such a devastating affect is a bit suspect, but the cited articles clearly show, “Smola, who believes that the SPLOST would have passed were it not for Avrit’s calls,” made that her excuse (a far cry from her senior-bashing explanation of today).

Now let’s discuss the how the FCBOE has lied to senior citizens on the school funding issue. In both the 2000 and 2004 school bond proposals, the following language was widely promoted, “Homeowners who qualify for the county’s elderly homestead exemption on school taxes would also be exempt from the school bond tax” (Plan For The Future brochure, 2000; Fayette County School Bond Support Our Children brochure, 2004).

Full disclosure: I strongly supported the 2000 bond issue and passively supported the 2004 bonds with the full intention of not having qualified seniors pay the bond tax as promised.

Yes, we the voters of Fayette County made a pledge to our senior citizens who qualified that they would not have to pay the exempt portions of the school taxes. This promise was in our bond literature. This promise is embedded in our tax structure.

Now, Ms. Smola, Fayette Citizens for Children and the FCBOE want close to $40 million of the debt service for the bonds to be diverted to sales tax revenues via the SPLOST.

Thus, senior citizens who were previously exempt will be forced to pay the debt service for the bonds through sales taxes (and we promised them otherwise). This backdoor tax conversion may not mean much to our young families, but to many of our seniors it makes a somber financial situation worse.

Here is where we get back to that issue of moral obligation. Forget about the other issues such as poor decision-making and lack of financial accountability from the FCBOE, and concentrate on this single issue of lying to the elders of our community while we sit back and watch pro-SPLOST personalities blame those same elders for past FCBOE failures.

Because this “Last Minute SPLOST” secretly fell from the heavens without warning a week after FCBOE members secured their seats in mid-July, there was no time to discuss the impact it had on our senior citizens. Had the FCBOE thoroughly vetted this SPLOST proposal as they did with the past bond proposals, perhaps we could have developed a solution to this problem.

Many of the big names in those political action committees who pushed the school bonds are in the process of absolving themselves of promises made, but not kept.

What exactly is the value of our promises? The government could care less, but what about we the voters?

We need to protect our senior citizens, keep our promises and express our disapproval of this questionable SPLOST which did not see the light of day until it was too late to have a public examination of its contents.

Currently, we have officials at the federal, state and local levels who act as though the laws of the land do not apply to them. We are expected to choke on the consequences of their actions.

We, as citizens and voters, made promises to the senior citizens that they would not pay on exempt bond taxes. This SPLOST referendum makes us out to be frauds. How about we do the right thing, the moral good, and keep that promise.

[Steve Brown is the former mayor of Peachtree City. He can be reached at stevebrownptc@ureach.com.]

login to post comments | Steve Brown's blog

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Submitted by kreedham on Thu, 10/09/2008 - 8:20am.

This is neither a commentary for or against the splost. I must say we, the citizens of Fayette County, asked for it. You say the board squandered their money and put none away for a rainy day. Yet we continue to reelect them, both on the board and on the county commission as well as State Senate, State house, et al.

If Smola is so bad, stand up for yourself and vote for the lady that is running a write in campaign. Then in two years kick out a few more. If we do this then they'll get the message that they must be responsible to us.

Here's a suggestion, if the person has incumbent by their name, vote for the other guy. I know I did in the primary (actually I think I voted for 1 incumbent).

Next year PTC residents can make a stand against that status quo and in 2 years we can get rid of some more incumbents on the school board and county commission.

gelato's picture
Submitted by gelato on Wed, 10/08/2008 - 10:11pm.

I am utterly disgusted with Mrs. Smola's behavior and the SPLOST fiasco, but your letter, Mr. Brown, now makes me have total disdain for that woman. I AM A SENIOR CITIZEN who no longer has children in the Fayette County School system - but will soon have grandchildren in school, and I take very personal offense to Janet Smola's stance towards Senior Citizens and the elderly. I pay as much tax as anyone else, I vote, I study proposals, and when necessary campaign so that penny taxes will be approved for the welfare of our community. The SPLOST has nothing to do with the welfare of our community...it has EVERYTHING to do with the FCBOE covering their rear ends after squandering irresponsibily money collected from the citizens of Fayette County, even us Seniors. They went on a field day with the money, not thinking of a rainy day...and Janet Smola is by far the worse offender; a virus. Keep the information coming, Mr. Brown, I for one am very interested in knowing the truth. I personally have discovered some very appalling things which should distress our whole community.


The Crime Dog's picture
Submitted by The Crime Dog on Wed, 10/08/2008 - 6:39pm.

Anybody remember the tennis center debt he (and his council) refused to pay for?

Sounds to me like EXACTLY the same kind of Wall Street logic that got our country into the fiscal crisis we're in now!

Sorry Steve. You're the WRONG PERSON to be lecturing the BOE about finances and honesty.

Back to the political graveyard with you!!!


Submitted by Jones on Wed, 10/08/2008 - 9:10pm.

How are you comparing the tennis center fiasco and Wall Street and Steve Brown? That's down right stupid.

Are you glad Wall Street is getting paid off with our money? I guess you are or you wouldn't write such stupid stuff.

There are a few of you bloggers who just can't stand it when Steve Brown is right. He stands up for the average guy.

His stuff on the E-SPLOST is better than anything Crime Dog or Mudcat has had to say. I'm voting NO.

The Crime Dog's picture
Submitted by The Crime Dog on Thu, 10/09/2008 - 9:52pm.

I certainly CAN compare Brown's tennis center loan fiasco with the Wall Street/bank crisis on mortgages.

Brown (and Rapson, Weed) agreed to default on a loan for a facility owned by the city. The loan was incurred by a fiscal arm of the city. With the city council's knowledge.

It's exactly like all those morons who bought too much house, stopped making payments and blamed everyone but themselves. Except the city had the money to pay for it, and so when the adults were elected to office the loan was paid.

Except the TC loan was made by a local bank with local stockholders. Pissing them off was the beginning of Brown's political end.


Spear Road Guy's picture
Submitted by Spear Road Guy on Fri, 10/10/2008 - 2:47pm.

Even some of the old development authority guys admitted they got the cash under the table on the tennis center.

I was a Logsdon supporter because of his stance on taxes, but I never believed the tennis center stuff was legal. So I got screwed both ways because my taxes keep going up and Mayor Logsdon used my money to payoff the stupid banker.

Vote Republican


Robert W. Morgan's picture
Submitted by Robert W. Morgan on Thu, 10/09/2008 - 5:50am.

In fact over half the people in the county will be right when they vote no on the SPLOST.

Being right is only part of the process of being an effective leader. After you are right on most of the issues, you must convince a majority of the voters you represent their best interests and will sincerely work for them. As Dan Schoor said "If you can fake sincerity, everything else is easy"

Then after you get elected you have to acknowledge that there are other leaders who are perfectly sincere in their beliefs and the way they govern and they may not agree with you 100% of the time - or not at all if come across as a cocky condescending know-it-all. You have to know how to compromise and play the game of give and take.

You have to understand that you represent 100% of the citizens and property owners (even those evil commercial property owners and the occasional developer with zoned property) and your decisions have to be right - which is defined as what is best for the city. And it it usually prudent for elected officials to follow the laws so they don't waste taxpayer money defending lawsuits. That part is easy - they actually give you an attorney who attends every meeting and gives you free (except for the taxpayers) legal advice. All you have to do is listen to him.

Again, the city is everyone, not just those that voted for you, but everyone. That's why the voters have little patience for a politician with personal agendas. That's why some politicians last only one term.

Yea, Jones, Steve Brown is right. He is usually right on the issues. But he's contemplating a run for Mayor or Council (Plunkett and Boone are both up and vulnerable) and that stupid column Cal lets him write for some reason is the root of his campaign. Save the above and take it into the voting booth next November and read it before you push the button for Brown. In fact, feel free to use it this November. You can apply this to any candidate for any office, but It would be impossible for any rational person to believe in this criteria and then vote for Obama, Westmoreland or Smola.


Spear Road Guy's picture
Submitted by Spear Road Guy on Fri, 10/10/2008 - 2:50pm.

Robert W. Morgan, even you'll admit Steve Brown would be better than Logsdon, Boone or Plunkett by a country mile.

I've learned arrogance is when you can't admit you're wrong. Been there, done that and not going back.

Vote Republican


mudcat's picture
Submitted by mudcat on Wed, 10/08/2008 - 7:17pm.

And he will respond with a 1500 word letter which Cal will happily print because he likes this tired old argument about the tennis center.

I agree completely that brown is irrelevant and does not need to be on the stage.


Submitted by Bonkers on Thu, 10/09/2008 - 2:02am.

Have you already paid your share of the 1.5 million owed for the Tennis Center? How much wuz it? Seems the worser things git, the more taxes go up!
Or, has it not been paid in full yet? Do you know? I don't!

Want a big ole Ize Rank, run bye dar, allsew?

Submitted by Nitpickers on Wed, 10/08/2008 - 6:53pm.

You actually "wanted" that hidden cost paid?

The bank made a "bad" loan, just as some have recently, and they should have had to eat it!

The Crime Dog's picture
Submitted by The Crime Dog on Wed, 10/08/2008 - 8:06pm.

The development authority had hotel motel TAX revenue rolling in.

'Twas a solid revenue stream til 1-term Clownie came along and screwed it all up.

Just like he whiffed on sales tax negotiations with Dunn, which cost PTC millions! At least Lenox would've gotten enough dirt on the county to broker a reasonable deal thru arm twisting.


Submitted by Bonkers on Thu, 10/09/2008 - 2:08am.

Did they stop collecting the tax, dog?
What is the Tennis Center and Airport doin fer money these days?

Submitted by Arf on Wed, 10/08/2008 - 12:27pm.

As a "senior" who resides in Peachtree City, I find it hard to believe that a case could be made that "seniors" are the cause of E-SPLOST failures currently or in the past.

Just who are these "seniors" who are against reasonable funding for education? I've lived here for over 20 years and raised my children in Fayette County schools. At present, I have grandchildren, nieces and nephews who are attending these same schools. So...even as a "senior" I am interested and concerned about the quality of education in Fayette County. Most "seniors" in this area are here because they either "grew on" here or moved here to be close to their children and their children's children. I think that it would be difficult to categorize most "seniors" in this geographic area as "old people who don't care about the schools."

I am not convinced that E-SPLOST is the answer, not because I am a "senior," but because I think that the spending has been unmanaged and out of control, and that "we" have been wasteful and unaccountable in some of the financial decisions that have been made. No one has yet tried to convince the public that the financial decisions of the past few years in this county have been in the best interest of the students or the county. Until I decide that FCBOE needs more money for quality education, I will vote against any further funding increases.

Find another group to blame, FCBOE. "Seniors" these days are still active, productive and are most concerned about "quality of life," education, the environment, property values and all the rest that concerns mainstream America. Just because we don't have kids in school doesn't mean we are not concerned about our extended families or the area in general.

alittlebirdietoldme's picture
Submitted by alittlebirdietoldme on Wed, 10/08/2008 - 8:53am.

Who is paying for these?...they are usually placed near other signs from a current FCBOE member up for re-election......hmmmmm......


mapleleaf's picture
Submitted by mapleleaf on Wed, 10/08/2008 - 10:22am.

These signs are put up by a campaign committee called Fayette Citizens for Children.

We probably won’t be able to know who finances this committee until it files its report with the Fayette Board of Elections on the report due date of October 20. Expect support from people who have something to gain from the $115 million the school system wants to spend.

This campaign committee is registered with the State Ethics Commission (www.ethics.ga.gov). But you cannot look up its registration statement unless your search is for Fayette Citizends for Children, with an extra d in the word citizens.

Neil Sullivan and Tracey Goodman are listed as co-chairs. The group has a website at yesfayetteESPLOST.org. It probably has support from people who are salivating at the thought of selling 5700 computers to the school system.


sniffles5's picture
Submitted by sniffles5 on Wed, 10/08/2008 - 10:35am.

Citizen education reporter Ben Nelms dropped the ball on this one, but if you go over to the Citizen's competition (which I will not link to out of respect to Cal) you will see that Neil and Tracey just received a huge $5000 contribution from the Fayette County Realtors association.

In my opinion, this money was most likely a gift from various developer interests in Fayette county, a political "wet kiss" thank you to Smola, Smith and Wright for pre-building a huge infrastructure of schools with our tax dollars, making it so much easier for developers to build subdivisions in remote corners of the county.

Smola, Smith and Wright overextended themselves attempting to please their developer constituents and now need a financial bailout courtesy of a $115 million SPLOST.

Smola, Smith and Wright benefit.
Developers benefit.
Taxpayers lose.


Submitted by hi grover on Thu, 10/09/2008 - 9:23pm.

It might be the sister of a certain developer that stands to make out big if the FCBOE builds the new high school...just a little food for thought.

alittlebirdietoldme's picture
Submitted by alittlebirdietoldme on Fri, 10/10/2008 - 4:38am.

2008 OFFICERS & DIRECTORS

Board Member Name Board Member Title Email Address
Dawn Scarbrough President / State Director dawnscarbrough@aol.com


suggarfoot's picture
Submitted by suggarfoot on Fri, 10/10/2008 - 4:57am.

that is not real smart of them...have they ever heard of ZIP reality, or for sale by owner?


Submitted by skyspy on Fri, 10/10/2008 - 9:16am.

I just closed on some more property for sale by owner. This is only the second time I have done this. Very easy. It saved the owners some money. Good experience. This is a good time to buy.

Submitted by NeilSullivan on Wed, 10/08/2008 - 11:40am.

The Fayette County Board of Realtors gave us $5,000 last Thursday. The Realtors understand as I do, that many people look to buy houses in Fayette County because of the high quality schools. I can't speak for them as to development, but these residents are people who felt that our cause was worth funding to help get the word out regarding this issue.

The rest of our donations are small and from people who support our cause. There are small business owners, teachers, retired teachers, parents, and most other type of Fayette citizen you can imagine. We have received checks from all over the county and donations on PayPal. I personally gave $30 and my family and Tracey's have donated our time to hopefully make a difference for the teachers, students, and citizens of Fayette County.

We are singular in our issue as we have people on our team that will likely agree only that we need the E-SPLOST to support our schools. For example I have a McCain Palin and a E-SPLOST sign on my lawn. My neighbor a few doors down as a E-SPLOST sign and an OBAMA sign. We do not take sides in any other race nor do we coordinate with any other committees. We feel the E-SPLOST should be considered by itself, and that the discussion should be a fact based discussion based on our situation today. We are people who are proud of our schools and want to help maintain our "Fayette Advantage"

My wife is a teacher at McIntosh and I am Manager of Financial Planning and Taxation at Rinnai America in PTC. Tracey is a former PTO president at Brooks Elementary and a partner in education. We met at an E-SPLOST presentation by FCBOE and felt that people should at least be presented with the facts to make whichever decision is right for them. We are working with many other people in Fayette County to do just that and nothing more.

I hope this answers your questions.

Neil Sullivan
Co-Chair Fayette Citizens for Children
www.yesfayetteESPLOST.org

gelato's picture
Submitted by gelato on Wed, 10/08/2008 - 10:26pm.

How fair is it for the FCBOE to make a presentation about the E-SPLOST, when it is their bad judgement and irresponsible spending which has us in the hole? Why not be really fair and invite those leaders in the community against the E-SPLOST to present as well, so that the community can truly make the right decision? Way too one-sided for me, and my senior citizen money.


alittlebirdietoldme's picture
Submitted by alittlebirdietoldme on Wed, 10/08/2008 - 12:03pm.

Why are you placing the signs with Smola's...also in the right of ways?


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.