Criminal activity in F’ville: Reality vs. perception

Tue, 01/15/2008 - 5:35pm
By: Ben Nelms

The perception of criminal activity versus the reality of criminal activity: That was the topic of a portion of a presentation by Fayetteville Police Chief Steve Heaton at the City Council’s Jan. 8 annual retreat.

Heaton addressed three issues relating to crime that he said were perceptions rather than realities. Issues cited included the community perception that overall crime is increasing in Fayetteville, that the Fayette Pavilion has a disproportionate amount of crime and that crime is worse in Fayetteville than in neighboring cities.

Citing the first issue, Heaton provided a statistical breakdown of the more serious Part I offenses such as aggravated assault, burglary, forcible rape and robbery. Heaton provided a chart listing separate totals for those offenses covering 2002-2007.

While individual crime categories showed increases or decreases, total Part I crimes fell from 652 in 2002 to 521 in 2007, a 29 percent decrease during the period.

Also addressed were Part II offenses such as disorderly conduct, fraud, non-rape sex offenses and driving under the influence. Part II totals for the 2002-2007 period showed an overall decrease of 7 percent, Heaton said. The decrease was accompanied by a 35 percent increase in population in the past seven years.

Heaton said the Fayette Pavilion area is sometimes perceived as being an area heavy with crime. That viewpoint would have been more easily substantiated in recent years rather than today, he said.

Council members viewed data that showed Part I crimes at the Pavilion in relation to overall crime in the city. The Pavilion had 52.08 percent of citywide Part I crimes in 2003. In 2004, the percentage fell to 43.91 percent and increased to 47.57 percent in 2005. A significant decline in Pavilion crime occurred in 2006 when the percentage fell to 30.30. During 2007 the percentage fell again to 29.61.

“The numbers of criminal offenses at the Pavilion are low with the exception of larcenies,” Heaton said. “Larcenies are the predominate offenses at the Pavilion. This is not surprising considering it is the largest retail center in the area.”

In addressing crime rates in the 22 cities across Georgia with populations of 10,000-20,000, Heaton provided a chart that showed totals for Part I crimes. Fayetteville is positioned near the middle of the list in terms of population, with an estimated 14,824 residents. Fayetteville came in at 87 Part I crimes per 1,000 persons, compared to 57 in Powder Springs, 64 in St. Marys, 113 in Calhoun, 186 in Tifton and 218 in Brunswick.

Fayetteville scored the lowest of any city in violent crimes per 1,000 persons, with a score of 1.35 compared to 2.24 in Suwanee, the next lowest, 3.67 in Powder Springs, 3.48 in St. Marys, 11.73 in McDonough and 27.26 in Brunswick.

Fayetteville scored in the middle range of officers per 1,000 persons, with 2.83 compared to a low of 2.07 in Powder Springs and a high of 4.0 in Brunswick.

login to post comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Submitted by depdawg on Thu, 01/17/2008 - 8:38am.

Stats are just that, they are stats. Who are the stats controlled by, the reporting agency, so yes they can be swayed or spun to fit whatever the topic for discussion may be. Because you can rest assured when any agency head goes to the city council, board of comissioners etc, they claim crime stats are up to get more positions. But when confronted by concerned constituents that same agency head will claim stats are down. First and foremost that agency head is a politician, elected or not, and it is all about keeping the residents happy. Here is an example or two that I have witnessed in my career:

Person breaks into a residence, but there are no good leads, lets title it a theft, they dont sound as bad. If we have good leads and can make an arrest lets call it a burglary, because catching a burglar makes good news.

You leave your purse on the front seat of your car and it gets stolen, but we have no suspects, we call it a theft. If i catch the subject in the act it is an Entering Auto charge, which is a felony and once again looks good in the Citizen.

DUI's are not down, there are no DUI task force officers in Fayette County. To say they are down is saying the crime has decreased, it hasnt there just aren't officers who are dedicated to making those arrests, they are tied up with the other non-existent crime in Fayetteville. I know for a fact a task force officer could average about 6 arrests Fri-Sun (DUI related). I know this becasue I averaged that for a substantial period of time.

Crime is down in the Pavilion, according to the stats, right? So the crime is down up there, but the crime stats are up in other areas now. I guarantee the stats in Cobblestone and Knights Way are up. Its great that the Pavilion issue has been toned down a bit, but to say crime in Fayetteville is down I dont believe is a fair statement to the citizens of Fayetteville and Fayette County.

Chief Heaton isnt a bad guy, and this isnt an attempt to make him look bad, but stats are just that, they are paperwork.

Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Thu, 01/17/2008 - 8:47am.

Where are your facts to refute what was said in this article? You seem to disagree, but have ZERO facts to back up your opinion. I do a good bit of business in Fayetteville, and haven't had any troubles at all. Would it make sense for me to come on here and say that there is NO crime in Fayetteville?

Submitted by 30YearResident on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 1:58pm.

There's a lot of sayings about "statistics" but my question is, "Do we show a decrease in crime, or in "reported" crime?"

I've heard from a number of people in the Fayetteville area that many of the criminal activities do not show up on the crime statistics report. It's an old trick police chiefs use to "prove" their effectiveness and keep their jobs.

I personally am dubious of the stated "drop" in individual crimes between 2002 and 2007. I would like to know if those are "apples to apples" statistical reporting details. You can show a "Drop" if you add catagories and move crimes around... basically, there are a lot of ways to skew the figures.

I don't believe this report.

Submitted by Eliza on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 9:08am.

I keep looking for a Citizen story on the following - these people were arrested a couple of days ago.

"ATLANTA -- Investigators across the metro area are adding up cases of a suspected husband and wife robbery team.

The Fayetteville couple is in jail in Henry County as detectives from at least a half a dozen agencies look into armed robberies dating back to August of last year.

Roslyn Ford-Calhoun and her husband, Preston Calhoun, lived in nice home in a nice subdivision in Fayetteville. They were raising their teenage daughters and their elementary school-aged children as well, but police alleged, between the parent-teacher conferences and the soccer games, the couple were robbing stores.

"We figure anywhere from 10 to 15 that they've done," said Det. Ron Waddell with the Smyrna Police Department.

They were a couple that had no problem doing things together, police said. Officials said Roslyn Calhoun and Preston Calhoun had everything worked out and would rob stores, like the Smyrna Family Dollar. . . . " (from - http://www.wsbtv.com/news/15047961/detail.html)

Git Real's picture
Submitted by Git Real on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 11:49am.

Clayton imports & Fayette exports....

They got away with 10 to 15? Usually the Riverdale mobsters only get away with 1 or 2. Crud.... now I gotta start fearing my white neighbors and their children. Oh wait... I'm ok. I from their hood.
________
In regards to Democrats, Republicans, gangs, and other scads of coterie Kool-Aide drinkers; Remember this..... Eagles Don't Flock


Submitted by Eliza on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 7:56pm.

If your response is about Mr. and Mrs. Calhoun - they are not white.

Git Real's picture
Submitted by Git Real on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 9:11pm.

There goes my 'Equal Opportunity' effort / opportunity to trash on some white trash robbers. I suppose I'll have to wait for the next child molestation case before I can go after a white Fayette County bad guy.

________
In regards to Democrats, Republicans, gangs, and other scads of coterie Kool-Aide drinkers; Remember this..... Eagles Don't Flock


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.