Police officers should learn how to apologize when they make mistakes

Tue, 01/15/2008 - 5:04pm
By: Letters to the ...

Having read both letters written by Mrs. Wendy Scales-Johnson published in your newspaper, I would like to offer two suggestions.

First, I must acknowledge that racial profiling does happen in Fayette County. I raised two sons in Fayette County, and they both were stopped on numerous occasions. One was stopped six times in 18 months; he was cited once for passing on the right. The other five times there were no violations cited.

This was 10 and 12 years ago and I had hoped things would have changed. The local NAACP has the stops made by law enforcement in Fayette County and Mrs. Scales-Johnson’s assertion is correct: Statistically, people of color are stopped at disproportionate rates to white citizens.

Specifically, in Fayette County, African-Americans make up approximately 12 percent of the population; however, the number of police stops of African-Americans is 37 percent of the total stops made.

While I applaud the men and women in blue who work hard to protect us daily, it is known that mistakes can happen when trying to apprehend a criminal. I even understand [making an error] in favor of caution.

However, once it is clear that a misidentification has occurred, what happens next could make all the difference in the world between a humiliating experience and a learning opportunity or one where officers are seen as abusing their authority, harsh and insensitive versus officers who seek to serve and protect.

Young people can understand why officers sometimes have to act in the way that they do. However, if officers are trained specifically on how to act once a mistake has occurred, police could avoid the reputation they sometimes get for using excessive force or abusing the power of the law.

The after-scenario could have gone something like this: “Gentlemen, they have apprehended the culprits in the case for which we have detained you. Although I am sure this must have been a very scary experience for you, having guns cocked and pointed in your direction, being handcuffed and detained. We apologize for that. However, please understand we were doing our job and we have to treat all suspects as potential criminals.

“The reason we pull our guns out is if you were indeed a criminal you could have a weapon and could have fired on us. So we have to be cautious. If ever you have a question about how we do our job, you are welcome to come into the police station and talk to our superior officers. If ever we get the wrong guy, we want them to know why we do what we do. I hope this explanation will help you understand what just happened this evening. My name is Officer X if you have any questions.”

I think although the gentlemen detained might have still been a little shaken, they would have appreciated an explanation.

I am an educator and I sincerely believe taking the time to educate helps to breed appreciation and understanding. When you don’t take the time it can breed contempt, mistrust, and hatred for the men and women in blue. Why take that risk?

I think every citizen of Fayette County should ask the question: “If what was reported happened to my young son or daughter, what would I want the police to do?” Then take your answer and share it with your law enforcement officers.

I would be horrified if this happened to my 16-year-old daughter. I suggest that officers receive training or retraining on what to do when they apprehend the wrong suspect. I think this suggestion is warranted in the light of these two recent incidents.

I would further like to suggest that the sheriff cancel the current citation and offer these impressionable young men an apology with explanation.

They did not stop and detain the gentlemen because of loud music, but because they thought they had committed a crime. To after the fact give them a citation, in my opinion, adds insult to injury.

If the court date holds, I think Fayette citizens available during that time should appear in court to witness the carriage of justice. I appeal to the county powers that be to take these suggestions under serious advisement.

A Fayette County resident of 19 years,

Dawn C. Oparah

Fayetteville, Ga.

login to post comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Submitted by Ed Holgren72 on Thu, 01/17/2008 - 11:07pm.

Mrs. Scales-Johnson would not be much of a mother if she did not support her son during his encounters with law enforcement. I would certainly be disappointed in myself if I did not support my children. That being said, supporting your children means to me that as a parent that you do exactly what you expect law enforcement to do--find out what the truth is.

Everyone and I mean everyone (my self included) relates events from our own perspective and includes our own biases and prejudices. That’s normal. Just as we expect law enforcement to do more than just accept our word, as parents we should do the same. After recently reading Mrs. Scales 1st allegation in connection with Chief Heaton's eloquent explanation of what really happened, I would hope she would have taken these words to heart--obviously not.

Wouldn't it be amazing to see the video from the camera in the patrol car that D/S Davidson was driving? I would be surprised to learn that he was driving his training officer's patrol car. I might even faint at the mere thought that the video might show that no law enforcement officers alleged that the whole incident had anything to do with a "gas drive off." Stunned is how I would feel to learn that actually the traffic stop was connected to a lookout on an off duty Fulton County SWAT officer's personal car that had just been stolen while having guns and such in it when it was stolen. Absolutely flabbergasted that the video would actually show that NO LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS HAD THEIR WEAPONS DRAWN AT ANY TIME is how I would feel. I would just be disappointed beyond belief that Mrs. Scales-Johnson's son would say on a video that he didn't stop at first because he didn't hear the siren on the deputy's car because his radio was so loud.

No, I'd be surprised if such a video existed; but Cool I'd sure be in court to see the video that MIGHT JUST MIRACULAEOUSLY turn out to be....

As surprised as I think I might be about such a video, I'd be more surprised if the Sheriff's Department will stand up for its people like the Fayetteville Police Department did.

Anyway...Just my thoughts.

The Crime Dog's picture
Submitted by The Crime Dog on Fri, 01/18/2008 - 12:04am.

Aha! Sounds like our buddy EdHolgren here is in the know.

Our first clue should've been the lack of apology from Mrs. Scales-Johnson for being WRONG in her first letter.

I can see how a kid might misunderstand in the heat of the moment why he was pulled over. But if there are no guns drawn ... someone should take him out to the woodshed and whip his behind!!! Here's hoping a daddy or father figure is around to do that, with the divorce rate being as bad as it is.

I've got to thank Mrs. Scales-Johnson for one thing though. She's proof that parents need to get their heads out of their butts and realize that their "little darlins" aren't so perfect after all.


Mixer's picture
Submitted by Mixer on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 2:11pm.

The assertion is that this Fayette County officer stopped these poor innocent kids for "Driving while Black"? Remember? I bet the cop does ... after all, he was called out in a public forum for being an alleged RACIST - his badge number and all.

Yet you yourself state that "They did not stop and detain the gentlemen because of loud music, but because they thought they had committed a crime. To after the fact give them a citation, in my opinion, adds insult to injury.

So, which was it?? Were they stopped for being black or not? Wouldn't you and your sons be stopped every day if that was the case? You are black every day aren't you? I know my son in law and my grandson are both black every day.

I am white everyday ... in fact, I was told I could not advertise my company on:

http://www.blackbusinesslist.com/

I guess I will hire my son-in-law.

And I am even further befuddled by your logic. If they stop you for speeding and you have a pound of marijuana ... you should not be prosecuted for the marijuana (stolen computer, dead body, etc.) because they actually pulled you over for 'speeding' and so that should be just a 'freebie' in 'Oparahland'? Riiiiight. Got it.

And finally, you are relying solely on the words of the teenagers in making a determination on how the police should have handled this situation? Wow.

I guess that's like students accusing you educators of something and the case being settled without ever hearing your side of the story ... no due process for cops and teachers! Great, yea, that will make those kids respect authority ... good call there Oparah. ((By the way, how do you know the officers DIDN'T explain the entire reason for the stop and apologize for the inconvenience .... and enforce the warrant?))

By the way - you ARE an active member of the local NAACP - don't you think you should mention that before you provide your 'unbiased' support of Ms. Scales-Johnson?

Personally, I think you should just stick to stirring the pot and pretending you are the only race that experiences any bias in life at the NAACP meeting and Board of Education Meetings and leave ticket writing to the professionals.

Have a 'Blessed Day'.

My favorite website.


Submitted by thebeaver on Wed, 01/16/2008 - 12:55pm.

"Specifically, in Fayette County, African-Americans make up approximately 12 percent of the population; however, the number of police stops of African-Americans is 37 percent of the total stops made."

Right. And I suppose the 70% rate of out-of-wedlock births in the black community are caused by the stork.

Ms. Oprah - can you provide a link that substantiates your claims?

----------------------------------------------------------------
“...the term “democrat” originated as an epithet and referred to ‘one who panders to the crude and mindless whims of the masses.’”

Submitted by IMNSHO on Tue, 01/15/2008 - 5:55pm.

Statistically, people of color are stopped at disproportionate rates to white citizens.

I quit reading after this statement.

Is it maybe, just MAYBE possible that IF more "people of color" are being stopped, it just MIGHT be because they are doing more illegal acts? I realize that is a very un-politically correct thing to say.

Are there more black males in prison because the cops are picking on them? I really don't see how that could possibly be, nationwide. (Mind you, I don't know what the racial statistics are for the prison population.)

All the cops need to pull someone over is a reason that can be as vague as "suspicious activity." So to say that they're being pulled over for no reason... you really don't know, do you?

The other five times there were no violations cited.

Hmmm. I've been pulled over and let go without a citation. Was I pulled over because of racial or gender profiling? I don't think so. And I truly doubt that is what happened with your son. I don't care what he told you "Ma, I wasn't doin' nuthin'!" We know that kids aren't always completely truthful with their parents.

Submitted by skyspy on Tue, 01/15/2008 - 5:27pm.

One of the teens in question had an outstanding warrant. He violated his parole from a previous "bad choice"(?).

Have you seen the tape from the police car?? I haven't either, I would love to be a fly on the wall when that is played in court.

You are assuming that this "mother" is telling the truth.

Since we do not have the kind of problems Atlanta PD has, I'm assuming the cop is telling the truth.

Submitted by susieq on Tue, 01/15/2008 - 10:01pm.

The teens I know don't get questioned by police because they don't hang around parked buses at night (or anything else that doesn't belong to them).

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.