Minimal savings from ousting attorney

Tue, 07/24/2007 - 4:34pm
By: John Thompson

A study by interim Fayette County Administrator Jack Krakeel conducted in June reveals that the county will probably see only small savings by hiring an in-house attorney.

On July 12, the Fayette County Commission voted 4-1 to proceed with hiring an in-house attorney to replace Bill McNally, who had served as the county’s counsel for 28 years.

Commissioners Eric Maxwell and Herb Frady suggested the county could save hundreds of thousands of dollars by going to a staff attorney.

But in the county’s study, obtained by The Citizen last week, the numbers don’t seem to back up that assumption. In conducting the study, Krakeel surveyed other counties and cities, along with looking at the county’s legal costs over the last four years.

In looking at other governments’ costs, Krakeel said the totals ranged from a low of $85,000 per year in Troup to $551,575 in Henry County.

Henry County spent $466,575 for a staff attorney and $85,000 on outsourced attorney fees. Neighboring Coweta County spent $327,000 for its outsourced firm.

The hourly rates ranged from $95 an hour in Coweta to up to $200 an hour in Douglas and Cherokee counties.

In analyzing Fayette’s legal expenses, Krakeel revealed figures that showed the county spent $402,971 in 2004, $501,431 in 2005, $621,083 in 2006 and $302,604 in 2007.

Krakeel explained that 2007’s figure was due to the resolution of litigation and the internal changes in the county to using legal services.

After surveying the other governments, Krakeel determined it would cost approximately $289,000 a year for a staff attorney that maintains an office in the county complex.

“Based upon the board’s direction to analyze the cost of in-house legal services versus an outside firm, it is the conclusion that the cost of establishing an in-house legal capability is comparable to the current cost of contracted legal staff,” Krakeel wrote.

Krakeel also explained that there were other factors to consider in making the decision.

“This would include the exploration of other alternatives to reduce overall legal expenditures such as reduce the number of billable hours of legal service through appropriate internal controls and established policy; renegotiate current contract rates and establish a formal cyclical process for the acquisition of legal services.”

Krakeel concluded his report by saying an administrative policy could be established to achieve additional savings in billable hours.

login to post comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Mixer's picture
Submitted by Mixer on Wed, 07/25/2007 - 12:16pm.

A Certified Check will be fine.
Thanks-

Taxpayer

Do you want to see some current examples of liberal media bias? Click Here.


Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Wed, 07/25/2007 - 10:36am.

Shouldn't things like this be discussed BEFORE taking action? I see no point in this now. The new Council has been bent on taking this direction for a while, and after they vote on it, we see it's really not going to save much at all. What's the point?

I was of the opinion, then, and now, that if it isn't broke, don't fix it. I don't see how this makes Fayette any better than it was before. These seem to strengthen my thoughts, even though they are a "day late and a dollar short".

Git Real's picture
Submitted by Git Real on Wed, 07/25/2007 - 10:53am.

Everyone seems to be forgetting that this is not ALL ABOUT MONEY. Where have you been dude? Shocked

CLICK HERE - If This Doesn't Help Then.......

**** GIT REAL TOUGH ON CRIME ****

"That man was Griffin Judicial Circuit District Attorney Scott Ballard".

CLICK HERE FOR THE REST OF THE STORY


Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Wed, 07/25/2007 - 12:02pm.

I just think it's shortsighted myself.

Git Real's picture
Submitted by Git Real on Wed, 07/25/2007 - 12:24pm.

Sorry... I'm trying to be nice here.

Ok... Remove your nose from where it doesn't belong and you can see past the massive heaps of whatever... This will enable you to see farther. If you don't have a problem with Mr. McNally's actions over the years then what's the point of continuing this conversation.

If you really feel this way then it's obvious as to your "industry sector" biases and that you're not as much of an independent thinker as I thought. Remember... Group VI and company doesn't have much clout on these blogs.

Sorry Dawg... Guess I got a little grumpy and perhaps needed a nap after my lunch. Eye-wink

**** GIT REAL TOUGH ON CRIME ****

"That man was Griffin Judicial Circuit District Attorney Scott Ballard".

CLICK HERE FOR THE REST OF THE STORY


Submitted by lawaboveall on Thu, 07/26/2007 - 4:22pm.

Git Real,

Why do you jump MD for expressing an opinion different than yours?

If he thinks that the county attorney should not be changed why does he have to automatically be an attorney? Can someone not have a contrary opinion to yours without your assuming they have an ulterior motive?

At any rate, let's call this what it is. Political pay back from Eric Maxwell to his biggest supporter and other cronies.

During the budget planning the commission put in $100k for an in house attorney because, Maxwell "felt" like that would be enough. No data, no study, just a guess from someone who had been in office for about 4 months. Just like the campaign rhetoric that the county was wasting $500,000 on lawsuits, this "feeling" turned out to be another
wrong (by about $400k).

So Krakeel does a study that indicates that there would be little if any savings by hiring an in house attorney. Gee, how did that happen? Why do you think McNally stayed around for so long?

Commission Board after Commission Board figured out that they were getting quality representation for a good price. They were being good stewards of the your tax dollar. As MD said, if it ain't broke why fix it. If it were not for Cal Beverly getting bent out of shape over the access to executive sessions, and the Sheriff's silliness, this would never have been an issue. So Maxwell,Frady (who lied to McNally and told him he could be county attorney as long as he wished earlier this year)Horgan (give me strength) and Smith went along for the ride.

We have suddenly gone back to the "good ole boy" politics as usual mindset in Fayette County. I had hoped that things had changed, but obviously that is not the case.

If you need any more evidence of a return to the "bad old days" you must have missed the article about Scott Burrell being asked to work on a defined benefit plan for county employees. There are four things wrong with this issue. First, this type of plan is something that Jack Krakeel has wanted for years and was refused repeatedly by the County Commission, so he had to wait for the change before he could get it started. Second, this type of plan is a passe' method of providing retirement benefits (not done any more in the private sector..too costly and many public plans are being eliminated).
Third, it fulfills a promise that Eric Maxwell made to Jack during the campaign and finally, it involves Scott Burrel, he of the questionable dealings during his tenure on the Commission.

So let's recap

In six months the new commission has :

Replaced a very capable county administrator because she wanted to do her job, and replaced her with an overly ambitious fire chief, who as a county administrator has already proven that he makes a much better fire chief.

Put together a budget which resulted in a tax increase to all county residents.

Increased the county payroll by 26 positions even as the county continues to shrink in areas of responsibility.

Eliminated a county attorney that has served the county with great loyalty (yes he got paid), and did what he thought was best for the county for 30 years all to save money. Oops...they did not save any money. So it really must have been political payback.

Forced the county engineer to resign because he was "not developer friendly enough" (he was actually enforcing the county ordinances).

All this in a bit over six months. Wow, what a record.

By the way, I am not Janet Dunn, I do not work for McNally Fox and I am a republican.

tortugaocho's picture
Submitted by tortugaocho on Thu, 07/26/2007 - 4:54pm.

As masterful as McNally was in closing government proceedings, he was sheer genius in hiding his bills. Krakeel is unable to make any form of value comparison because no one has ever compiled McNally's billings let alone evaluate them. Large corporations will do detailed analysis of hourly billings. Here, you and Krakeel are guessing. You are doing the same thing you accuse Maxwell-- you are guessing as to the economic impact. Saying we won't save money is ludicrous because no one knows what McNally tapped us for. BTW- I define loyalty as something other than harrassing the other cities in the county.

Mixer is right--- please put that "small savings" in my account.

Git Real is right--- performance issues exist which justify the heaveho.

The Commission has voted. Stop whining.


Git Real's picture
Submitted by Git Real on Thu, 07/26/2007 - 4:36pm.

I MIGHT get back to you later. Right now I feeling to giddy and "chilled out" to deal with your hooey. But if I must... I'll muster up the energy and send you packing as usual. I had a rough night and I'm fix'in to start my vacation. So rather than lay out the same ole irrefutable facts over and over again I think right now I'd rather P-A-R-T-Y.

Maybe later......Cool

**** GIT REAL TOUGH ON CRIME ****

"That man was Griffin Judicial Circuit District Attorney Scott Ballard".

CLICK HERE FOR THE REST OF THE STORY


Submitted by lawaboveall on Thu, 07/26/2007 - 4:40pm.

Clever retort. I could care less if you respond. You have often castigated me for being such a mean person and the only response you can give is hooey?

Do your research while on vacation. You will need it.

Git Real's picture
Submitted by Git Real on Thu, 07/26/2007 - 5:26pm.

You have often castigated me for being such a mean person and the only response you can give is hooey?

Think about how you've so viciously attacked Jack and Eric in the past. We've gone around the horn several times with each other and each time you run off like a dog who's been shot with a BB gun for digging in the garbage. So if hooey is what you want to dish out then hooey is what I give back.

Now go lay back down and lick your wounds and continue feeling sorry for the election loss you experienced last year. Good grief... you call yourself a Republican but you're acting like Democrat still whining over Gore's loss. Cool

**** GIT REAL TOUGH ON CRIME ****

"That man was Griffin Judicial Circuit District Attorney Scott Ballard".

CLICK HERE FOR THE REST OF THE STORY


Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Wed, 07/25/2007 - 12:39pm.

to hire an attorney, as we spent the entire year of 07. Huge savings for sure. Where? Why would ONE attorney put his entire welfare into the hands of 5 guys who would just as soon vote him out of a job as not?

I have exactly NOTHING to do with those entities you mention.

Exactly how do you see that Fayette has suffered under the former "regime" of Attorney's? The findings seem to speak for themselves, and we'll still need outside help.

God help anyone on this board who thinks that Fayette County has actually done a good job in the past. I guess they want it to more closely resemble our neighbors.

Mixer's picture
Submitted by Mixer on Wed, 07/25/2007 - 12:35pm.

Did you have Crackers? Or maybe a HUNKY of cheese? Did 'Casper' the 'ghost' come visit you? Was it your 'Not so GREAT' KlanDaddy?

You had a GREAT blog in response to Davids (sic) mom.

(I wonder if she is really Donna Brazile.)

Do you want to see some current examples of liberal media bias? Click Here.


Git Real's picture
Submitted by Git Real on Wed, 07/25/2007 - 12:44pm.

Twasn't quite sure what that was I ate. Smiling

Ahh... I don't think David's Mom is an idiot like ole Brazile. Anyways.... overall she seems to be a reasonable person. And, It's said that reasonable people can come up with reasonable solutions. So... I'm hoping she, you and us can get past this and start battling the Black Hate Thugs and the KKK White Trailer Trash types together. Out of that I think much respect and good will would arise.

This race junk is ever so tiring......

**** GIT REAL TOUGH ON CRIME ****

"That man was Griffin Judicial Circuit District Attorney Scott Ballard".

CLICK HERE FOR THE REST OF THE STORY


Mixer's picture
Submitted by Mixer on Wed, 07/25/2007 - 1:44pm.

I look forward to a time when 'her', 'take back fayette' and 'the beaver' can comment on something other than race.

I have noticed the only time race comes up is with people that either aren't from around here or failed the audition for the Jerry Springer show.

Do you want to see some current examples of liberal media bias? Click Here.


Submitted by Davids mom on Wed, 07/25/2007 - 1:12pm.

Thanks.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.