Dog shot by hunter: Did Fender deserve this?

Tue, 11/14/2006 - 5:03pm
By: Letters to the ...

“Dear Mom, Dad and Fender: If Fender drives y’all too nuts, tell him his best friend will be home soon ... Can y’all bring Fender when you visit for family day next weekend? ... Give Fender my love. Love, Justin”

That was an excerpt from a post card written on Nov. 4 by our son, Justin, who is attending basic training with the U.S. Army at Fort Benning. This is the story of Fender, his dog, left in our care over eight weeks ago.

Little did he know when he wrote those words that we would bury Fender that evening. If that wasn’t difficult enough, the worst was yet to come. How would we inform Justin in order to minimize the impact on the crucial life and death training he was undergoing at Fort Benning.

Fender didn’t have to die. He didn’t die of old age, disease or accident. He was intentionally killed by a bullet fired from the gun of an irresponsible and callous hunter. The incident occurred on property behind our house and within 200 yards from where we were calling for Fender that evening. As darkness fell, at least five shots were fired in our direction; “trigger happy” comes to mind. No menacing deer were bagged that day, only a small dog.

Justin had rescued Fender as he strayed along Ga. Highway 85 last spring and an instant bond was established. He nursed him back to health and Fender instantly became everyone’s friend and one of the most active pets we’ve ever been around. His favorite pastime was to chase and retrieve tennis balls. Fender didn’t have a vicious bone in his body and was so grateful for his second chance at life. When the day was done, and the balls and toys put away, he would find a lap to snuggle on, lay his head against your shoulder and fall asleep.

Despite our best efforts to restrain him this day, he managed to escape. We started our search at 4:30 p.m.; it ended at 6:15 when [a man] came to our house with the unbelievable news. His exact words were disturbing: “Your dog was running deer; therefore, I had no choice but to shoot him.” He was quick to hide behind Georgia statute 27-3-49(c) which reads: “It shall not be unlawful for any person to kill a dog which does not have a collar and which is pursuing or killing deer in any locality ...”

According to the statute, in all other instances where dogs may be “pursuing or killing” deer, only a conservation ranger, sheriff, or deputy sheriff can engage that dog with the intent to kill it.

Fender was wearing a bright blue collar with an identification tag attached. Ample contrast was provided against his beautiful light brown coat; there was no mistaking the presence of a collar unless you were seeing what you wanted to see. At 40 pounds and 20 inches high, he was not that day, nor had he ever exhibited a threatening appearance.

Additionally, he appears extremely healthy and domesticated from any distance, not to be confused with a wild, scavenging animal you would envision pursuing and killing deer for food.

That is what makes this situation so hard for us to accept. We hardly think the framers of this statute intended for hunters to have complete discretion to indiscriminately kill any dog wandering into their killing field. [The shooter] will tell you he didn’t see Fender’s collar and he was running his deer off – no excuse. When in doubt of your target, we assume the responsible hunter would confirm its legitimacy before pulling the trigger, particularly in this situation.

We contend that our hero [hunter] was at the end of an unproductive hunting day, and took his frustration out on helpless Fender. There is no other logical explanation for this senseless act. The area he was hunting in has several homes in and around it; therefore, the prudent person would safely assume that any dog that wanders in the area is probably someone’s pet. Think about it, [hunter]. And you’re trusted with a deadly weapon near my house? Shame on you and your inability to make rational decisions before pulling the trigger.

This past week, we were able to inform Justin about Fender’s death. As we were, he was shocked and saddened beyond words. He’ll take it like a man, however, because that’s what he is.

What irony: Our son is serving his country to ensure people like [the hunter] can benefit from his sacrifices and have the freedom to enjoy weekends hunting deer. Unfortunately, it appears [the hunter] fails to appreciate his fortunes and enjoys taking advantage of his freedoms. We feel sorry for him and anyone condoning his malicious actions that day.

We are deeply saddened and miss our beloved pet deeply. There is an enormous emptiness in our home without our spirited little friend who truly defined unconditional love. Do we sound upset? We are. The inexcusable senselessness of this act will take us a long time to get over.

Finally, to the pet owners residing in Fayette County: Be aware, if you violate the county leash law, your pet is subject to be killed, and the killer is able to return and hunt another day.

Robin and Fred Edwards
Fayette County, Ga.

login to post comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Submitted by sharkbrew on Sat, 12/02/2006 - 1:35pm.

Dear Fred, Robin and Justin,
I am sorry to hear about your loss. The irresponsible hunter should have his hunters license taken away. My husband is a deer hunter but would never take action like that. It's not like it was a wild cayote attacking the deer it was a dog being a dog running after what is moving in the woods. He could have started out chasing a squarrel and happen to come accross the deer in the woods and continued his case. Why not shoot a warning shot in the air to scare Fender off instead killing Fender for being himself, a dog. Deer come back to the same place you idiot hunter you should know that. But Fender wont not any thanks to you. I will say a prayer and thankyou to Justin for fighting for our country unlike those who have a gun and can't control themselves in shooting harmless family pets b/c it messed up their day of hunting deer.

-Kelly W.

Submitted by cheryl and bob on Fri, 11/17/2006 - 7:21pm.

Dear Fred,Robin and Justin, we were so sorry to hear about your loss of Fender. Its a terrible thing when people who shouldn't own guns are allowed to roam free and do what they want to. we were also given our sons dog Smokey- a basset hound -2 years ago when our son Jeff was sent to Kuwait-we flew to Virginia to pick him up and fly him home to Colorado - he totally trusted us to take care of Smokey while he was serving our country-we have since been given him for good and i can't even begin to imagine if something would have happened to him while our son was gone and we had to tell him. We really feel for all of you and hopefully the right thing will be done to this person. We know you can't bring Fender back but just know if your hearts you took wonderful care of him and made his days full of good memories-thanks for sharing and you will all be in our thoughts and prayers in the days to come. take care. cheryl and bob frankart

Tug13's picture
Submitted by Tug13 on Wed, 11/15/2006 - 10:57pm.

We have a dog, he is part of our family. He was adopted through a animal shelter. Reading your letter broke my heart. It also made me furious. How can anyone be so stupid to shoot at anything that moves??? Who is the person that did this? My heart goes out to you.

Please tell your son Justin THANK YOU, and BE SAFE.
My prayers are with all of you.


AF A-10's picture
Submitted by AF A-10 on Wed, 11/15/2006 - 7:20pm.

I am so deeply sorry that this has happened to you. When I was in my 2nd year at the Air Force Academy, the dog which was my best friend for 18 yrs died of old age. That was hard enough. But to have your pet taken by a very irresponsible hunter (and I will stand behind that contention) is tragic. To yield deadly force upon what clearly is a dog, without taken due care to check for a collar, or even a threat if uncollared, is INEXCUSABLE! I am not against hunting or guns, but one must posses EXCEPTIONAL judgment, in my opinion, if you are to carry and discharge fire arms. Rash hunters like this man have killed people in their own backyards. They have shot fellow hunters. And saying you are sorry won't bring people or pets back from the dead.
If the hunter in question cares enough to read any of this, please heed this: When in doubt, DO NOT SHOOT! The worst that will happen is you miss a dear that day. The best that can happen is people like Justin will return home to the wagging tails of their beloved pets. In 1999 I was flying an A-10 in Northern Kuwait. I lined up a shot to the north with the sun in my eyes. The sight through the HUD (heads up display) wasn't what was being described to me by the Army ground controller, so I chose not to shoot; and three Kuwaiti civilians in a Datsun pickup are alive today because of that decision. You don't have to take every shot. But I guess this is written too late.

God Bless,

Kevin Hack King


Submitted by myword_mark on Wed, 11/15/2006 - 6:17pm.

I'm sorry for your loss. Thank your son for his service to our country.

Shooting defensless animals like deer is bad enough- but anyone that could shoot a family pet is a sicko who needs to be watched closely.

Maybe if the bastard would have served his country in the military he wouldn't feel the need to prove his manhood by hunting.

God's speed.

Submitted by skyspy on Wed, 11/15/2006 - 5:32pm.

This idiot was shooting towards your home? I thought there were laws about how close you could fire a gun next to a residential home?

Not that it is ever enforced, but still......wow I thought things were bad here in the 9th ward.....I'm sorry for your loss.

Very little of Fayette county is rural anymore, where is it legal to hunt? I thought only rural areas were used for hunting.

This is a story out of the twilight redneck zone.......you might be a redneck if you have to shoot someone's pet to feel like a man.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.