Criticizing Islam: Must I now go into hiding?

Tue, 10/31/2006 - 5:04pm
By: Letters to the ...

Though I spent my boyhood in Los Angeles, I am a fortunate resident of Fayette County, as are my parents. At one time I lived and worked in France. Los Angeles Times staff writer Jeffrey Fleishman recently reported that a French philosophy professor, Robert Redeker, has been forced into hiding after writing in Le Figaro that “Jesus is a master of love; Muhammad is a master of hatred. ... Islam is a religion that, in its very sacred text as much as in some of its everyday rights, exalts violence and hatred.”

Shortly after the article appeared, French intelligence services informed Redeker that radical Islamic Web sites had published his picture, his phone number and a map to his house. Redeker said one threat stated, “This pig should have his head cut off.”

It seems to me, as a Christian, that that French philosophy professor may have gone too far in his sweeping assertion regarding Islam. Yet what he said should in no way have caused him to have to preemptively flee for his very life.

Professor Redeker lives on a European continent where the influence of Christianity has progressively waned, while the power of Islam has increasingly waxed (Europe is now peopled by approximately 15 million Muslims, most of whom take their beliefs very seriously, while Christians in Europe who actively practice their faith are a single-digit blip on the radar screen.)

It is now a sad day in Fayette County when, as a husband and father, I must think twice about speaking out. Yet, as a second mosque (I mean, “Islamic Cultural Center”) is being constructed in our midst, I am compelled to pose a question to my fellow Fayette residents, regardless of their religion.

Which key, historic figure carried a cross and gave his life for others, and which carried a sword and took others’ lives?

Now that I have asked, will I have to flee, too?

David Bobkowski
Fayetteville, Ga.

login to post comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
FourLeggedWord's picture
Submitted by FourLeggedWord on Fri, 11/03/2006 - 10:08pm.

Surely you're not implying that further introduction of Islamic culture into our community poses a threat on our right to free speech.
Your accusations against Muhammed are no more legitimate than those raised against the heroes of the Old Testament, such as Joshua, conquerer of Jericho, and David, conquerer of the Chaldeans, Assyrians, and Babylonians. Did these men not fight in the name of the same god?
And to whom are you defending Jesus? To Muslims? Do they not view Jesus as a prophet and a martyr?
If you raise the factor of Islam's bloodied past, then certainly you cannot be forgetting Christianity's equally violent history. What about the Spanish Inquisition? The Klu Klux Klan? The Holocaust? However, these figures and events are no more representative of the modern Christian principle than Middle Eastern terrorists are of Islamic doctrine.
So please, Dave, you're hurting my ears. Take a cue from your messiah, and show a little tolerance.


David Bobkowski's picture
Submitted by David Bobkowski on Wed, 11/08/2006 - 12:27pm.

Sincere thanks for your comments. I did not mean to hurt your ears. The intent of my Letter to the Editor was not to hurt anyone. I felt I had the right to voice concerns that I have about fearing to be able to speak (not act) up. You make some good points in your reply. The history of mankind is replete with violent things done in the name of religious belief. I just don't know of any devout followers of Jesus Christ who are true to his teachings in the New Testament and are threatening to kill or are actually killing anyone in his name or to defend his honor. If this is happening, please tell me where. In all fairness, there are myriads of devout followers of Mohammed who do indeed threaten to do violence or actually do violence in the name of the Prophet or to defend his honor.
Please correct me if I am mistaken.
Yours,
David Bobkowski


Submitted by dollaradayandfound on Wed, 11/08/2006 - 5:24pm.

NO religious devout follower would kill randomly as the terrorists do, nor as we do and have done before (atom bomb). About 75,000 to 100,000 Iraqis have also been killed since 2002 by "devouts." Many of us do not speak up against that either!

Submitted by AMDG on Sun, 11/05/2006 - 9:00pm.

FourLeggedWord,
Mr. Bobkowski's point was that if you say something negative about Mohammed or Islam, you risk being the target of threats and real violence. If you think this is not true, you are simply disconnected from reality. The proofs of this pathology are too numerous and too obvious to recount.
He is worried about the possibility of some those not-too-uncommon Islamic extremists coming in to our county along with the moderate, reasonable ones. THis is a legimitate concern.
To say that Christians are just as guilty and cite examples like the Ku Klux Klan and the Holocaust is silly. Name me one example of Christians becoming violent in the street in reaction to an insult to Jesus Christ or the history of the religion itself.
Islam began its spread with the sword and has relied on violence for its expansion ever since. There have been tolerant, moderate Muslims and regimes, but the history is dominated by violence and by a holy book which extols violence as a means to conversion and expansion.
The New Testament is completely devoid of such sentiments. The initial expansion of Christianity occured in spite of violence directed at its followers, not by violence perpetrated by them. The history and fundamental world-view of the 2 faiths couldn't be more different.
Examples of violence done in the name of Christ are usually fallacious, inaccurate, or, at best, examples of individuals abusing the name of the Faith and acting in contradiction to its principles.
Please explain to me how Muslim terrorists are acting against the principles of Islam, and your answer would need to be comprehensive and take into account the contradictory statements on violence in the Koran.

CenterMass's picture
Submitted by CenterMass on Sat, 11/04/2006 - 3:41pm.

“This pig should have his head cut off.”

It sounds like a threat to free speech to me. I find it interesting that you can condemn someone as intolerant for expressing his legitimate concern for safety but failed to address the central issue of his letter…the Islamic death threats.

We live in a free society that enables us to express our thoughts and ideas, popular or not, without the fear of reprisal. In this open forum, no person, subject or entity is provided a protected status that exempts them from scrutiny, discussion or criticism. If that is more than the Muslim community can bear, perhaps it does not belong in a free society.


Tug13's picture
Submitted by Tug13 on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 3:11pm.

I would like to know, have you have received any replys or comments re your letter? I agree with you one hundred percent!


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.