Wholesale club part of plans for west PTC

Tue, 10/31/2006 - 4:39pm
By: John Munford

Newly released plans to build a large shopping center on the south side of Ga. Highway 54 west are of such a scale that the development would have been forbidden under Peachtree City’s old big box ordinance.

But the new ordinance, adopted in March, allows the developers of McIntosh Village South to seek a special use permit from the Peachtree City Council that would allow the stores to be built anyway. The change was made to make the ordinance less susceptible to a legal challenge, but even if a proposed development meets certain criteria, council can still turn it down, City Attorney Ted Meeker said when the new ordinance was adopted.

The McIntosh Village proposal will be presented to the City Council at its regular meeting Thursday night; developers are seeking feedback on the project. It includes more than 343,000 square feet of retail including an unnamed “wholesale club” at 135,000 square feet and a Kohl’s Department store at 89,000 square feet.

The city’s current big box ordinance limits the size of individual stores to no more than 32,000 square feet, and the size of retail developments to no more than 150,000 square feet.

The McIntosh Village South proposal includes land stretching from the current Days Inn parcel all the way to Planterra Way.

The developers of McIntosh Village South, Capital City Development and Flexxon Operating, are also seeking a land swap with the city to acquire a 3.8 acre tract in exchange for a parcel that includes part of the lake at the city-owned Line Creek Nature Area, which is southeast of the proposed development. The City Council voted earlier this year to consider the land swap but council has not yet approved the land transaction.

The city parcel has a small amount of frontage on Hwy. 54. City Attorney Ted Meeker has noted that the city will need to gain land of equal or greater value for the swap to take place.

One of the proposed entrances for McIntosh Village South will line up with Hwy. 54 and MacDuff Parkway. In addition to another entrance further east on Hwy. 54, the draft version of the plan shows a roundabout being built on Planterra Way just south of Hwy. 54, with a leg of the roundabout leading to a third entrance to the shopping center. It is not clear if the developers are proposing to build the roundabout or not.

In other business, council will consider lifting the city’s multi-family housing moratorium to consider a project on Newgate Road near the Kedron Village shopping center that would add 21 townhomes in six different buildings. The proposal is being brought forth by Pathway Communities, which owns the 5.6 acre parcel, although another company, Weatherup Construction, is under contract to build the development.

The tract is currently zoned for general commercial use and is designated as commercial on the city’s future land use map. The townhome project, as a residential project, would ultimately require a rezoning to be approved by council.

Council is also scheduled to consider annexing a 13-acre parcel on the city’s southern border to allow a four-building office complex off Ga. Highway 74 proposed by Group VI Corporation. The city’s planning commission has recommended approval of the annexation.

The parcel extends from the city limits along Hwy. 74 all the way to Redwine Road; part of the tract is adjacent to Peeples Lake. A previous proposal to have one of the four buildings used for retail was withdrawn after the Fayette County Commission objected to it.

If the city annexes the property, it will be responsible for providing fire, EMS and police service to the property and for maintenance of additional state right-of-ways and multi-use paths, City Planner David Rast noted in a memo to Council. Group VI has estimated that the parcel will generate about $40,000 a year in taxes to Peachtree City, Rast noted.

login to post comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
G35 Dude's picture
Submitted by G35 Dude on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 9:52am.

In a couple of years you won't be able to tell the difference.


valleygirl's picture
Submitted by valleygirl on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 12:03pm.

Riverdale wasn’t a planned community and neither was Fayetteville.

Peachtree City has controls in the master plan that will keep this town from every remotely resembling Riverdale. Despite everyone’s complaints about the progress here, I can tell you from experience that the growth here won’t harm property values or our way of life here. I came from a planned community in California and it went through all of this stuff years ago and still is a beautiful place to live. My sister is still there and she loves it. I don’t remember where the info a week or so ago came from, but someone was complaining that Ptc wasn’t in the top rankings of the country’s safest city anymore. That might have more to do with the shooting at a party and the one at NCR years ago as well as the one that happened recently. We also have been at the forefront in the news for catching internet predators (not criticizing that, keep it up!) And I don’t know how all that effects our standing. What I found interesting was that my old town was at the top of the list! Mission Viejo California was #1 as the safest city in America. They went though all of this growth too. They have a mall, Home Depot, Walmart, Lowes, and lots of fun restaurants and shops. There are places to play and work just like here. They even have a community College. They have areas around them like Riverdale, but their town didn’t change because of the master plan concept and the landscaping & sign ordinances.

People, Growth is inevitable and we have handled it just fine. The Avenue is wonderful, the Home Depot/ Walmart development is turning out nice and so has the Target Center. We need a new anchor at the Braelinn Shopping Center (we have all agreed on that) but overall the growth has been good for our community. I ‘m glad I don’t have to go up to Atlanta for things anymore and I’m glad the tax revenue for the things I buy is staying right here in our community now. The businesses looking to locate in our area look at the convenience of having all of these perks available. We want the businesses to locate here because that increases our tax base and our property values (supply & demand folks).

I’m not upset about all of the plans for growth because it isn’t an unknown factor to me.
If you look at the benefits it brings and you plan ahead it all works out fine. Smiling


G35 Dude's picture
Submitted by G35 Dude on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 3:14pm.

Valleygirl,

With all due respect, your logic seems to be it didn’t happen there so it won’t happen here. I think it will and here’s why. Look at the counties that surround Fayette. Clayton, Coweta, Spalding, and Fulton. They all have higher crime than Fayette. So how did Fayette manage to be an island in this sea of crime so to speak? There was no reason for the criminals to come here. They want places that have a high density of retail stores. That is what attracts shoppers with valuables. People with valuables are what attracts the criminal. A Fayette County deputy himself told me that the Pavilion was the worst thing to ever happen to Fayetteville for this very reason.


Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 3:38pm.

I don't think it's reasonable to keep out all commercial/retail. Fayette used to not have any commercial demand because the population did not justify it.

A Community based solely on residential isn't realistic, to me anyways.

I'm still not positive this is the best use of this property. Kohl's and Sams do not excite me at all.

G35 Dude's picture
Submitted by G35 Dude on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 4:07pm.

I never said keep out all comerical/retail, I refered to high density retail. The orginal plan for PTC was to be 5 "villiages" and a clean industrial park. Each villiage was to have a villiage center that would include a small shopping area. Thats not even close to what we're getting. And this wasn't my proposal. It was what PTC was "planned" to be.


Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 5:16pm.

I agree, the West Village is "morphing" before our eyes. I've said elsewhere, whoever approved the Walmart/HomeDepot etc before the roads were improved should be run out of town. I really have no use for a Walmart myself, but obviously folks love the place.

40 years ago, retail was MUCH different than now. Malls were all the rage, and that's gone out of style for sure. I don't think people ever envisioned as many different fairly large stores as we have now. I still think we should be able to do much better than Kohls and Sams (if that's what it is).

Also, it is hard to pick and choose what part of the old plan we want to keep. The old plan called for twice the population we have now. I'm certainly glad that part is out of the picture.

Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 1:32pm.

Nice post.

cowtipn's picture
Submitted by cowtipn on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 12:40pm.

Well Put ValleyGirl.


Git Real's picture
Submitted by Git Real on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 10:12am.

Just look at Fayetteville for proof.


Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 10:11am.

That's laughable...BUT, if you want to put $$$ where mouth is, let's look at the property you own in PTC, and what it would be worth in Riverdale, and I'll more than likely buy it. When can we get started? Smiling

Submitted by skyspy on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 9:58am.

We can be worse than crimedale oooppps I mean riverdale. I was hoping the value of our homes would hang in there for another 8yrs. Thats when I'm eligible to retire. I hate to have to move now before the value of homes tank in this city.

Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 10:18am.

I see nothing that is taking us in that direction. A few well managed shopping centers/roads certainly isn't going to cause a problem.

cowtipn's picture
Submitted by cowtipn on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 10:45am.

It's not the shopping centers that are causing the problems, it's the people they attract from outside Fayette that come in to shop. Like Dude and Git Real said, we built the Pavillion in Fayettville and welcomed Claytonians and thier money with opened arms. Next thing we know, five managers are tied up and robbed at gunpoint at Tinseltown, there are 1-2 cars broken into a day, people are getting beaten and shot, rats are pooping in the popcorn; and our officials are suprised by this? Granted, Coweta isn't Clayton; but it isn't Fayette either and we used to protect that. Every day, that line gets blurred and it's a shame.


Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 1:34pm.

to shop at a Kohls. Or a Wholesale Club, if they even approve it. Having been to BJ's in Newnan yesterday, we probably missed the boat on a NICE department store, Dillards has a great looking building right across the street. That would have been a MUCH better alternative than Kohls.

DragNet's picture
Submitted by DragNet on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 1:17pm.

So what exactly do you propose we do about "these people"?
How about a wall in the Fayette/Clayton county line and a sort of "border patrol"?

Man, some of these blogs are just dumb.

-----------------------------------
Making you think twice......


Git Real's picture
Submitted by Git Real on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 2:48pm.

We'll just put a noose around your neck and hang you on the "Welcome To Fayette County" sign. That oughta do it wouldn't you say?

See...not all blogs are dumb.


DragNet's picture
Submitted by DragNet on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 3:23pm.

...we could threat to shave all Claytonians to make them look like you!!

I'm beginning to see your point...

-----------------------------------
Making you think twice......


Spear Road Guy's picture
Submitted by Spear Road Guy on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 9:10am.

Wow, what a shocker, Harold Logsdon and his buddies are pushing more large scale construction projects on Highway 54.

It's sad how the article says that Logsdon changed the law related to big boxes in March. With the crap in Coweta County and the mess we're making on Highway 54, we'll grind traffic to a dead stop.

Blogger McDonaghDawg is a real piece of work. He's for all kinds of development. Never seen one he didn't like. He used to say he moved to Peachtree City because the development took over his old home. "What the hell, let's make the City of Peachtree look just like everywhere else!"

Between Rep. Westmoreland, TDK and now this whopper on Highway 54, I'm feeling very different about what was once a very charming place to live.

Vote Republican (except Westmoreland)


Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 10:13am.

IF you can show me, then I'll talk, otherwise, you are just another mud slinger.

Isn't the property in question currently zoned commercial? I would have been in favor of waiting on the Walmart-Homedepot until the road was finished myself. I didn't live here then, who was in charge then?

I'm on record against every zoning change there has been, I think the West Village is too dense and I was against the changing of the Church at Peachtree Parkway to a 24 hour drug store. Your facts don't match up with your claims.

Spear Road Guy's picture
Submitted by Spear Road Guy on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 3:16pm.

McDawg:

Every square inch of the property in East Coweta needs to be rezoned - that's been in the newspapers. Even the PTC proposed big boxes require exception approval according to the article above. Are you in favor of those changes? I'm not.

As for no one driving a distance to go to Kohls, you've got to be kidding. People drive from Clayton to the Avenues to shop.

Go drive up GA-85 and keep saying to yourself that just adding a couple more well managed shopping centers won't matter. That's what they used to say. That's what they have been saying on Bullsboro Road in Coweta for over a decade - now they are all complaining and raising their taxes to build bigger roads.

Vote Republican (except Westmoreland)


Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Thu, 11/02/2006 - 3:33pm.

But I hear you about the big boxes, I'm not sure we need them either, Especially Kohls. Re the Avenue, there are shops at the Avenue, that are present no where else on the Southside of town. And the stuff they sell isn't cheap. I'm over there a good bit on my golf cart, and I don't see a tremendous amout of Clayton Tags myself.

As far as adding centers in PTC, we don't have hardly any more room. I think we agree on much more than we disagree. We both realize the land won't sit vacant, it's too valuable for that. We don't have many more chances to make decisions. We either try to control what is built and work with them to make it as nice as possible, or get something crammed down our throat by a Judge.

Whoever was in office when the present West Village was approved should be run out of town on a rail.

Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Wed, 11/01/2006 - 10:14am.

Lots of folks I know have been wanting a Wholesale Type Club. I only hope it's Costco, but Sams wouldn't surprise me. Neither has a store on the 85 South Corridor. Being as the property is on the main 4 lane, makes sense to me. I'm surprised they aren't looking further toward Newnan to be closer to the interstate.

Why can't they get the cart paths around the new bridge finished? how hard must that be?

cowtipn's picture
Submitted by cowtipn on Wed, 11/01/2006 - 10:10am.

Farewell Old Peachtree City; I knew thee well.


Submitted by IMNSHO on Wed, 11/01/2006 - 12:39am.

That is what I expect to hear from the Planterra Ridge folks... and I don't blame them. When they purchased their $300K+ homes, I think they had a reasonable expectation to not have a Sam's Club in their backyards.

I can't believe I missed the big-box ordinance being changed in the city. Is this something else we can thank Logsden for, or was it in the works before him?

Submitted by McDonoughDawg on Wed, 11/01/2006 - 10:16am.

and commercial. What would make them think this property wouldn't go that way?

I seriously doubt it will impact them much at all. In fact, many, many of their residents will shop there.

Submitted by IMNSHO on Wed, 11/01/2006 - 10:22am.

...and I've never been able to figure out why people want to live there. I've warned out-of-towners away from there, when they're looking to move to PTC.

What happens to the Line Creek Nature Preserve? Will it be sitting in the middle of a parking lot now?

mudcat's picture
Submitted by mudcat on Wed, 11/01/2006 - 6:49am.

This wasn't in the works under Brown. He wouldn't allow such a thing as protecting the city from legal challenge to come up - things like that aren't important to him. Logsdon dreamed this whole thing up and got it passed in his first 2 months in office and got it planned next to Planterra Ridge just to spite those people - Brown's neighborhood, you know.

Sam's Club! How great would that be!
meow


Submitted by GloriaG on Wed, 11/01/2006 - 8:13pm.

That area has been zoned light industrial/commercial since the 1980s. Planterra Subdivision wasn't even there then. Residents should have known what would happen. Once Walmart goes into an area it's going commercial-just a matter of time. Have you ever seen a Walmart sitting out all be itself somewhere?

mainframecpu's picture
Submitted by mainframecpu on Wed, 11/01/2006 - 1:50pm.

Smiling


Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.