By DAVE HAMRICK
Editor-at-large
A majority of Americans don't want President Clinton impeached even if he lied
under oath about Monica Lewinsky.
It's a perfect example of what can be learned from polls... often nothing.
Clinton apologists in the national news media keep repeating such polls as proof that
the American people are behind the president and approve of his performance.
If you put the question that way, I would be among the majority saying the
president shouldn't be impeached. You certainly
couldn't conclude from that statement that I am a
supporter of the president. Nothing could be further from the truth.
There's a big IF involved. IF that's all there is. As the old song goes, "If that's all there
is, then let's keep dancing."
There are steps Congress can and should take if the investigation shows beyond
reasonable doubt that the president had a
dalliance with a young intern. Reprimand or
censure won't really punish him, but these steps
would at least state the sense of Congress and the nation that presidents shouldn't fool
around with employees and interns.
I know many of you want more than that. But let's look at the situation in the cold light
of reality.
In reality, it's true that any corporate CEO in his place would probably face dismissal.
But it's also true that the president is not hired
by a board of directors that can have a quick meeting in the dead of night and fire him.
He is hired by the American people, and dismissing him is a painful public process
that requires Congress to consider the severity of the crime.
If at some point in the process of investigation there is proof that Lewinsky is telling
the truth, Clinton will go before us on television and apologize. He will say that he lied
to protect his family, and he will ask our forgiveness.
Those of us who have always resented this president's cynicism and his view of the
American people as just so many suckers to be fleeced in the carnival of life will find in
that confession one more reason to be angry. But
is it enough to make him the second president in history to be impeached? (The first was
Andrew Johnson; he was impeached in the House but escaped conviction in the Senate by
one vote.)
Take a mental journey back through history and I think the answer to that will be obvious.
True, lying under oath is perjury and it's against the law. But we can't show that
lying in a civil trial about a personal matter has
done great harm to the country.
This does not mean that Clinton is out of the woods when it comes to impeachment.
With the attention of the national media focused so tightly on the stains on
Monica's dress, we forget that there are much
broader issues that will be included in special
prosecutor Kenneth Starr's report. The Lewinsky matter is a minor one, and if it's all Starr
has, then this investigation has been a hollow one indeed.
Let's not forget that there is ample evidence that this president has used the power of
public office to reward his friends and punish his enemies, and that Clinton, the First Lady
or both were up to their elbows in illegal real estate deals. We don't have the final report
on this, and it may not include proof of direct involvement, but it is certain to be damning.
Next, we have admitted violations of campaign laws. Starr's report will reveal
more about the extent of those violations, but we know the president and others in his
administration willfully violated those laws
because they have not denied it. Instead, they
keep calling for the writing of new laws to divert
our attention from the fact that they violated the old ones.
We also know that the president took illegal campaign contributions from the Chinese
and then turned over lethal nuclear technology to them, creating a direct threat to
American security. I'm not sure we shouldn't be
talking about a trial for treason on that one, not
just impeachment.
I have heard and read enough to satisfy me that all of the above, plus more, is true.
Whether Starr has sufficient proof to satisfy the
requirements of impeachment is another matter. I don't know.
We'll all know more when the final report is released. May it be soon.