County moving away
from electric vehicles, using more propane By DAVE HAMRICK
dhamrick@thecitizennews.com
Fayette
County is moving toward propane gas rather than
electric vehicles in complying with federal
requirements concerning alternative fuels.
The
county will spend $134,733 to install a new
propane fueling island at its McDonough Road
public works facility, increasing its holding
capacity from 1,000 gallons to 6,000 gallons, and
is stepping up its orders for vehicles that will
run on both propane and gasoline.
We
have two in the fleet now and six on order, with
seven more to be ordered, public works
director Lee Hearn told county commissioners
during recent discussions.
Federal
agencies are requiring local governments to
gradually convert the majority of their fleets to
alternative fuels to reduce emissions. It's part
of an effort to improve air quality in the
Atlanta region.
Within
five years, Hearn said, 70 percent of Fayette's
fleet will be composed of bi-fuel vehicles.
For
the last two years, the county has experimented
with electric vehicles, which perform much better
on air quality standards than vehicles that burn
natural gas or propane.
But
the electric vehicles are just not
practical, said county fleet manager Bill
Lackey.
One
of the three electric trucks owned by the county
has had mechanical problems, and if it hadn't
been under warranty the repairs would have been
much more expensive than on a normal vehicle,
said Lackey. And the initial cost of the vehicle
is almost twice that of a comparable gas-powered
model.
And
although improvements are being made, currently
an electric charge on the vehicles doesn't last
long enough to suit county purposes, he said.
If we were in the city of Fayetteville
where we would have a shorter perimeter to drive
them in, it might be all right, he said.
But right now propane is the way to
go.
One
bi-fuel Ford F-150 pickup truck, currently on
order, is priced at $19,379, Lackey said,
comparable to the cost of a gas-only truck.
Federal
requirements are that the bi-fuel vehicles spend
at least 90 percent of their time running on the
alternative fuel, propane. That's not a problem,
said Lackey. They can run pretty much the
same distance on propane as they can on
gasoline, he said.
Commissioners
wondered whether it was necessary to upgrade the
county's fueling station now, with only a handful
of vehicles using propane. I don't like us
to move any more quickly than we have to,
said Commissioner Linda Wells. But Hearn pointed
out that under its cooperative agreement with
local governments, the county provides a fueling
station for Fayetteville and Board of Education
vehicles as well.
After
complaining that the alternative fuel requirement
is another federal mandate that is totally
unfunded, Commissioner Greg Dunn made the
motion to approve the expense. The motion passed
4-0, with Commissioner Harold Bost absent.
|